LineSpeakerSt TimeContentEn Time
1LES_int_010.8112Okay.0.9736
3 1.2722So, I mean do you- If you don't mind,3.1380 
5 3.2434just telling me a little bit about yourself, li- and start with when and where you were born.7.4378 
6LES_se0_ag4_m_017.6046Okay. I was born on May the fifth, nineteen twenty-nine.10.2607
7LES_int_0110.2607Mm-hm.10.6997
8LES_se0_ag4_m_0110.6997At the Jewish Hospital in Brooklyn, Park Ave- uh,12.9931
9 13.0809Park Place and Franklin Avenue.14.4237
10LES_int_0114.5686Okay.14.9319
11LES_se0_ag4_m_0115.3325Um.15.7584
13 16.7945I-17.0535 
15 17.1808I spent17.7735 
17 18.5418most of my life19.5413 
19 19.7301the early life,20.4413 
21 20.6855first sixteen years of it anyway,22.0350 
23 22.5003in Brooklyn.23.1924 
24LES_int_0123.3680Okay.23.6446
25LES_se0_ag4_m_0124.0002Um.24.2812
27 24.4274I went to public school forty-four, /RD-SCHOOL-3/ High School,27.0236 
29 27.6338and then I-28.4636 
31 28.6963you know, I went away to college.30.0660 
33 30.8299Um.31.1285 
35 31.3919After grad school, I went into the Air Force, and33.9894 
37 35.4207I-35.6007 
39 35.7236you know, I had a ROTC commission, so I had to37.7240 
41 38.0884pay back that couple of years.39.4406 
42LES_int_0139.8046Yeah.40.0788
43LES_se0_ag4_m_0140.1738And while I was in, and just before I42.4524
45 42.5533you know, got42.9748 
47 43.1109um,43.4007 
49 45.5855this is45.8226 
51 46.0465just before I came out of the service, um.48.0748 
53 48.6060Um.49.0582 
55 50.1982I gave my mother enough money to buy an apartment here on the Lower East Side, and that was in Nineteen,54.4963 
57 55.1592um,55.5675 
59 56.5406fifty-six.57.3616 
60LES_int_0157.8841Okay.58.1606
61LES_se0_ag4_m_0158.2880And, so she bought this co-op.59.4821
63 60.6192The incredible thing about that, and I think that relates very much to this whole thing about Lower East Side issue.65.5743 
64LES_int_0165.7236Yeah.65.9738
65LES_se0_ag4_m_0166.4172Um.66.8651
67 67.0538The Co-op, I- we paid twenty seven hundred dollars for it.69.5372 
69 70.2089It is now worth four hundred and fifty thousand.72.6060 
70LES_int_0173.2909Where is it?73.7328
71LES_se0_ag4_m_0174.0050You know. So, what that means75.4275
73 75.5416quite specifically is that-76.8543 
75 77.2275that77.3592 
77 77.7631poor people are being marginalized right out of their neighborhood.80.3255 
79 80.4396pretty quickly.80.9489 
80LES_int_0181.0982[Yeah.]81.4714
81LES_se0_ag4_m_0181.2738[Okay.]81.5021
82 82.0421But anyway, that82.5602
84 82.8631you know, the- after the - I84.0836 
86 84.2680I didn't live in it85.0451 
88 85.2470for a long time, because after87.0455 
90 87.2211the Air Force,87.9455 
92 88.5382you know I got married and I lived in-90.1802 
94 90.9309in Harlem for a while,92.2114 
96 92.8172then I moved back to Washington94.4855 
98 94.9728uh, for several years.96.2636 
100 96.9573And [then,]97.4885 
101LES_int_0197.4051[Washington,]98.1104
102 98.2465[uh,]98.4309
103LES_se0_ag4_m_0198.3475[<ts>] Washington [DC]99.2562
104LES_int_0199.0675[DC.]99.4889
105LES_se0_ag4_m_0199.4889Yeah, I went to /RD-SCHOOL-7/ in [Washington DC. I hadn't]101.7104
106LES_int_01100.7577[Ah. Mm-hm.]101.4382
107LES_se0_ag4_m_01101.9519I hadn't mentioned that.102.8080
108LES_int_01102.9880Yeah.103.1592
109LES_se0_ag4_m_01103.4314Both for graduate and undergraduate [school.]105.1333
110LES_int_01104.9094[Okay] /?/.105.7125
111LES_se0_ag4_m_01105.9894And uh, I moved back to Washington DC, then, then eventually109.0231
113 109.1109moved back to New York.110.4265 
115 111.0543And um.111.7787 
117 113.3811I- I had a major in psychology,115.2865 
119 115.4095and I couldn't.116.2333 
121 117.1597My first job was in /RD-WORK-8/, which is a mental institution in Washington DC.121.2470 
123 121.7504And I couldn't stand123.3397 
125 123.7436uh,124.0070 
127 124.1080being locked in to go to work.125.8333 
128LES_int_01126.5138Mm.126.9002
129LES_se0_ag4_m_01126.9968A- and over- I was really overcome by that whole process.129.9280
130LES_int_01130.2616Yeah.130.5558
131LES_se0_ag4_m_01130.6085And and it- i- i- interestingly, what it did to me was i- it um,134.1806
133 135.9762Somehow, transmorphed into-137.9607 
135 138.1451into, um,139.0538 
137 140.1016a feeling that I really141.4450 
139 141.5855couldn't help those people.142.9948 
141 143.7894Because144.4260 
143 144.6192you know, they were145.1724 
144LES_int_01145.4314[Yeah.]145.8953
145LES_se0_ag4_m_01145.6713[Institutionalized]146.7118
146 147.0323i- i- in a locked in148.2528
148 148.4109sort of basis, with mental illness150.4436 
150 150.7816which meant, they were really sick.151.7460 
151LES_int_01151.9260That's right.152.3694
152LES_se0_ag4_m_01152.3738And- and I just felt I153.5855
154 153.8314you know,154.0992 
156 154.2528me,154.5909 
158 154.7928I- I'm not a155.3109 
160 155.7719PhD or an MD, I'm just a guy that took a masters in158.6284 
162 158.9226tests and measurements.159.9982 
164 160.5689a- and so, that, you know, I was doing that sort of routinized thing you know a-163.6318 
166 163.7635works-164.2114 
168 164.4020works above you, MMPS, all that kind of [stuff.]167.3241 
169LES_int_01167.1924[Yeah.]167.4953
170LES_se0_ag4_m_01167.8377And as I said, I can't really help people like this, and it's beginning to depress me so,171.8884
172 172.4504I took173.0036 
174 173.6314the training174.4743 
176 175.1065that I received175.9743 
178 176.5757and176.8962 
180 177.8226turned it into178.6348 
182 178.8982a marketing skill.180.2241 
183LES_int_01181.0802Hm.181.2382
184LES_se0_ag4_m_01181.2382Mkay.181.6143
185 182.1938I became a marketing researcher.183.8928
187 184.1563I did184.5119 
189 184.7533really very good work here in New York City, and that186.9353 
190LES_int_01187.0758Hm.187.3963
191LES_se0_ag4_m_01187.4885lot of187.8206
193 188.5450And then I moved from that189.8797 
195 190.3319into190.8850 
197 190.9772the advertising agency, was the first Black to be193.8996 
199 194.2596um,194.6504 
201 194.7338an account executive on an important account at a major advertising agency in New York City.199.2207 
203 199.7592Um.200.2070 
205 200.6679And uh,201.3440 
207 202.3143you know, formed an adg-203.2055 
209 203.3109a organization called /RD-WORK-9/ that was committed206.9164 
211 207.3905in the um208.1720 
213 208.3740in the sixties, the mid-sixties210.2120 
215 210.6291to try to increase the212.0339 
217 212.4115presence of212.9779 
219 213.3642blacks213.8384 
221 213.9745in the214.2247 
223 214.3828advertising [business.]215.4568 
224LES_int_01215.0398[Mm-hm.]215.3998
225 215.5447Mm-hm.215.8564
226LES_se0_ag4_m_01216.3349And216.6115
228 218.0866eh- I- I must admit, I- I was b-219.9437 
230 220.2115I don't220.4223 
232 220.5101for some ex- inexplicable reason, I was222.7224 
234 222.9858pretty successful223.7760 
236 224.2458as a marketing executive.225.4751 
238 225.9185And, and then I aggressively recruited by the /RD-WORK-6/229.4653 
239LES_int_01229.9330Mm-hm.230.1964
240LES_se0_ag4_m_01230.4159to um,231.0569
242 231.3159I was recruited as232.1984 
244 233.7686manager of marketing services and235.6081 
246 235.7749you know, just kind of moved through that.237.3247 
248 237.9657Um.238.3828 
250 239.4744Became240.2208 
252 241.0769the very first black person to ever publish243.5442 
254 244.3568a-244.5368 
256 244.9012a-245.0943 
258 245.3490world wide246.0207 
260 246.4026magazine247.1270 
262 247.3027that was not edited es-248.5743 
264 248.6841re- especially for African Americans, [I published]251.2831 
265LES_int_01250.7433[Mm.]251.0550
266LES_se0_ag4_m_01251.6080Stereo Review, Popular Electronics, and four or five other254.2889
268 254.9037um,255.2023 
270 255.3516annuals that were related to that. I had offices in258.0077 
272 258.3501four offices in two countries,259.8121 
274 260.2116um260.5014 
275LES_int_01260.9696Wow.261.2462
276LES_se0_ag4_m_01261.3603I- I had a really spectacular career doing that.263.9155
277LES_int_01264.2931Yeah.264.5126
278LES_se0_ag4_m_01264.5126And.264.8594
279 264.9911I did that for about thirteen years, and then moved from that into um,268.4886
281 269.3008the269.4940 
283 269.8321Vice President of marketing for the corporation. I was only the third272.7830 
285 272.9191Vice President of Marketing. They've only had four throughout274.8640 
286LES_int_01275.2679Mm-hm.275.5350
287LES_se0_ag4_m_01275.4216i- i- in the- in the fifty year history for the company.277.5757
288 278.4274And um,279.0596
290 279.2308then I279.6874 
292 280.2055when I got tired of that, I became Vice President in charge of starts and283.3211 
294 283.4967acquisitions and mergers and things like that, so I285.7752 
296 286.4952and then286.9650 
298 287.1713somehow, th- I felt288.1548 
300 289.4440really wasn't what I wanted to do,291.0377 
301LES_int_01291.1957Mm.291.5030
302LES_se0_ag4_m_01291.5030you know, to create all this wealth293.0616
303 293.7201for- for one- a single family or295.4923
305 295.6328family and other people.296.9806 
306LES_int_01297.0728Yeah.297.3713
307LES_se0_ag4_m_01297.9289And and s- it was- it was a funny kind of thing, but I300.7475
309 301.3079s- thought I had enough juice303.2616 
311 303.7928to304.1352 
313 304.7235start my own consulting firm.306.3084 
315 307.1953And307.5098 
317 307.6415the whole308.0279 
319 308.1508thrust of it was, I was gonna provide these high level marketing services311.5972 
321 311.9528to-312.2206 
323 312.5938to minority persons who were trying to314.7699 
325 315.1395get business, or couldn't access that [otherwise.]317.3391 
326LES_int_01317.2205[Right.]317.4716
327LES_se0_ag4_m_01317.5893I lost a fortune.318.7264
329 318.9415[<laugh> You- you know because I- I did a lot of work. (laughing)]323.1926 
330LES_int_01318.9415[<laugh>]323.0581
331LES_se0_ag4_m_01323.5059[And, um.]324.1820
332LES_int_01323.7781[<laugh>]324.3357
333LES_se0_ag4_m_01324.7176You know, people didn't have money or they couldn't pay, whatever the [situation was.]328.5911
334LES_int_01327.8755[Yeah.]328.3979
335LES_se0_ag4_m_01329.1574Um.329.4692
337 330.0794It was good though. You know, it kept me active.332.1940 
339 332.4750Kept my mind active.333.3530 
341 333.8008Um.334.2004 
343 334.7360And then,335.2452 
345 337.3159I found this church.338.4179 
347 339.0677Found this church. It was340.0573 
349 340.2706right after my mother died in nineteen,342.0004 
351 342.1321I guess,342.9863 
353 343.9610ninety-three,344.9312 
355 345.0541thereabouts, and345.8927 
357 346.1912I joined this church,347.2581 
359 347.9473and348.3161 
361 349.8247all of a sudden, I was reminded of a life long ambition that I'd had. I wanted to be an episcopal minister for years.355.3945 
362LES_int_01355.5789Mm-hm.355.9213
363LES_se0_ag4_m_01356.0925But,356.3120
365 356.4394as time went on,357.5940 
367 357.9419I- I had become so secular359.4126 
369 359.9131so hedonistic,360.9712 
371 361.2302that I thought that this couldn't. Oh that'll never work, [you know (laughing) <laugh>]364.4204 
372LES_int_01363.7930[<laugh>]364.7150
373LES_se0_ag4_m_01364.6136[given] the life that I had led.366.0229
374 366.5277Uh.366.8438
376 367.0634When I s-367.4497 
378 367.6297started speaking to /spo-/368.3629 
380 368.4551Father /RD-NAME-2/ about it,369.3683 
382 369.7327/with this/, in terms of him sponsoring me.371.6083 
384 372.4557<ts>372.5698 
386 373.4084And then we had another priest here, that was, and I was talking to him about it and he-376.4113 
388 376.9425And he said very simple thing to me, that m-378.7323 
390 378.9254that allowed me to379.5664 
392 379.7640proceed. He said,380.6376 
394 382.6835said,382.9864 
396 383.0918the Lord doesn't call those384.8991 
398 385.9440you know,386.3040 
400 386.5147who are ready387.3225 
402 387.6079to serve.388.0820 
404 389.1928He makes ready390.2932 
406 390.4820those that he calls.391.6235 
407LES_int_01391.6235Mm.392.1064
408LES_se0_ag4_m_01392.4752So, I s- well, you know, it made eminent sense to me, [so they-] at least gave me the juice to enter into what was an incredible process, you know, because399.2479
409LES_int_01394.6879[Mm-hm.]395.0435
410LES_se0_ag4_m_01399.8011I said,400.1830
412 400.4069I didn't want to401.4782 
414 402.3064didn't wanna become a priest403.4347 
416 403.6410at that age404.4796 
418 404.7079cause I was in my sixties then.406.2094 
419LES_int_01406.4903Right.407.0040
420LES_se0_ag4_m_01407.1050And um,407.7065
422 408.5366I said, but I wanted to be a deacon because in a410.7668 
424 410.9468episcopal church,411.9610 
426 413.6102there are three levels of ministry, there's a bishop, he has charge of a large area, like417.3903 
428 417.5176city of New [York.]418.2233 
429LES_int_01417.9511[Right.]418.4209
430LES_se0_ag4_m_01418.7457Then, there's a priest, he had charge of the gathered flock of him in a church.422.5170
431LES_int_01422.6560Yeah.422.8755
432LES_se0_ag4_m_01423.2091And there's the deacon whose424.6579
434 425.2726image is always426.1770 
436 426.6599the person standing in the door, looking out into the world,429.6043 
438 429.9994and so the responsibility431.3692 
440 431.6940is to432.2823 
442 432.6818take the message of the church out to the people434.6833 
444 435.0301[in the street.]435.6096 
445LES_int_01435.0301[Ah.]435.3594
446LES_se0_ag4_m_01435.8364So, the idea of a street ministry437.3905
448 437.5574truly appealed to me438.7120 
449LES_int_01438.9491[Yeah.]439.4364
450LES_se0_ag4_m_01439.3003[you know.]439.5506
451 439.9764So, you know, I studied for four years, and ho- but then I was ordained443.4520
453 443.6057in um,444.0930 
455 444.2159in May of two thousand, and reassigned to this church.447.1881 
457 448.0296Um.448.3852 
459 449.5618And i- it- in-450.4267 
461 450.7691um.450.9008 
463 451.0193During that period, just before ordination, uh, like um453.4164 
465 453.9374they started this Slave Galleries Project, uh,456.0798 
467 456.8437this church has the457.7430 
469 457.9501peculiar anomaly of459.1706 
471 460.0866two slave galleries was a part of it's original architecture,462.9447 
473 463.3135[and]463.6603 
474LES_int_01463.3135[Huh.]463.6603
475LES_se0_ag4_m_01464.8720So,465.3462
477 465.7106Father /RD-NAME-2/'s whole thing was that467.5662 
479 468.2159because of this whole gentrification phenomenon,470.3013 
480LES_int_01470.4637Yeah.470.7711
481LES_se0_ag4_m_01470.8764that471.1530
483 471.3725you kn-471.5921 
485 472.0032the f-472.2535 
487 472.6398the children473.3686 
489 473.5091of the families represented by our congregation here,476.0379 
491 476.5296would not be able to live in this neighborhood.478.4730 
493 478.6091Yeah, like my son couldn't afford to buy my apartment.480.9403 
494LES_int_01481.2081Hm.481.4759
495LES_se0_ag4_m_01481.9676Okay.482.3277
497 482.7974So, um, I'm- I'm gonna give it to him eventually, but484.8901 
498LES_int_01484.9735[Right.]485.2720
499LES_se0_ag4_m_01485.2105[you] know, if he had to buy it, he'd really be in [trouble.]487.3662
500LES_int_01487.0193[/unintelligible/]488.0203
501LES_se0_ag4_m_01488.0950So,488.4769
503 489.2672Uh.489.4647 
505 489.8891He said that490.3588 
507 490.5300Well, we need to do something491.7637 
509 492.3125that-492.5584 
511 492.6725that will survive us.494.2530 
513 494.8940And so,495.3067 
515 495.4340it was his idea496.5275 
517 497.4978that497.8183 
519 498.0802perhaps,498.7782 
521 499.9943this- the [restoration.]501.3685 
523 503.5938Hello.503.9055 
525 504.4807The restoration and preservation of the galleries and it's [all.]507.3592 
526LES_int_01508.0880<laugh>508.4787
527LES_se0_ag4_m_01508.8387Don't worry.509.2602
528LES_int_01509.3787<laugh>509.6717
529LES_se0_ag4_m_01509.8561Of the sla-510.3742
531 510.4839slave galleries, um511.7308 
533 512.2971would probably provide enough information514.3362 
535 514.8938you know515.1528 
537 515.2362to515.4909 
539 516.7230to serve as a testament517.8557 
541 518.1850to the presence of African Americans here520.1035 
542LES_int_01520.6128Okay.520.9114
543LES_se0_ag4_m_01521.2494long521.8333
545 522.0776you know, before anybody r-523.1620 
547 523.2894ever gave credence to that.524.5669 
548LES_int_01524.8655Right.525.1684
549LES_se0_ag4_m_01525.2606So, I thought you know I said you know, that's really a good idea. He said, well, I'm glad you like it because you got it.529.3377
550LES_int_01529.9919<laugh>530.4034
551LES_se0_ag4_m_01530.5450And I said,531.4450
553 532.1079I said, look, I'm a businessman turned minister, I don't know anything at all about restoration, preservation, or history. I hated history.537.9631 
554LES_int_01538.1343[<laugh>]539.5611
555LES_se0_ag4_m_01538.7094[You know.]539.0518
556 539.6972But,539.9870
558 540.1435luckily for us, we had this um, longstanding re-543.0060 
560 543.1684um,543.4011 
562 543.5328relationship with the Tenement Museum.545.0650 
563LES_int_01545.7396Uh-huh.546.0733
564LES_se0_ag4_m_01546.1655And so, they agreed to partner with us and548.3079
566 548.4396to548.5801 
568 548.8391act a fiscal conduit and550.3494 
570 550.6435show us how to really get into this whole idea553.3640 
572 553.7591of um, [restoring] a historic site.555.9279 
573LES_int_01554.3356[Right.]554.6622
574 556.1826Right.556.4811
575LES_se0_ag4_m_01556.7577So, I- I literally signed on558.3103
577 558.4245with them as a consultant559.6274 
579 560.5362uh, for three years, which was interesting, because I was562.9772 
581 563.1045a paid consultant, but I was really learning565.3025 
583 565.7635the whole thing.566.3167 
584LES_int_01566.3957Mm-hm.566.9050
585LES_se0_ag4_m_01567.1157Um.567.5679
587 568.1123And so we got started on the research, and we did570.2840 
589 570.6264the research on two levels and572.0269 
591 572.3694we raised about573.1860 
593 573.3133alm- nearly a quarter of a million dollars for575.1879 
595 575.4733for this, for interns, and whole /like/.577.3684 
597 578.0269And we were doing research on a genealogical580.2835 
599 580.7972you know, who581.5962 
601 581.8933who were the people who started this church,583.4781 
603 583.8118who sat in those galleries, that whole aspect of it.586.1167 
605 586.6699Um.587.0738 
607 587.7367And588.0601 
609 588.4157on the architectural, what could the space itself. The ghosts of the space. What could it tell us? [You know.]593.3504 
610LES_int_01593.1045[Yeah.]593.4558
611LES_se0_ag4_m_01593.9826So,594.3894
613 594.7845o- it was amazing because596.1894 
615 596.6899we immediately began to get a lot of ink,599.1422 
617 599.3134a lot of press about it, a lot of600.8284 
619 600.9162people began to be601.6801 
621 602.0006you know, interested.602.8743 
623 603.5855Um.603.9235 
625 604.8060And,605.1704 
627 605.2933we were encouraged to proceed,607.0311 
629 607.4570but607.6765 
631 607.7687of course,608.2604 
633 608.3921now608.7828 
635 608.9585it had gotten so large610.3194 
637 610.6838that the Tenement Museum611.7755 
639 611.9774they were pretty much forced to613.0794 
641 613.1892cut us loose.613.9355 
642LES_int_01614.3131Yeah.614.7828
643LES_se0_ag4_m_01615.0989And you know, with their blessing, and so here I am on this thing, I said oh,617.8721
645 617.9731God, you know. What do I do now? [/You know/.]620.2604 
646LES_int_01619.5316[<laugh> You're on your own.]621.4194
647LES_se0_ag4_m_01620.8970[So,]621.1736
648 621.4853Yeah, so what I did was, we- we formed this corporation, not for profit corporation, called r- called /RD-WORK-6/.627.5553
650 628.1087And our mission is to629.2282 
652 629.7052to-629.9335 
654 630.7194to-630.8379 
655LES_int_01630.9257Mm-hm.631.1409
656LES_se0_ag4_m_01631.3472you know, just to632.2384
658 632.7521enhance and follow through on the whole concept635.1185 
660 635.4111of the restoration and preservation of the637.2462 
662 637.9092of the slave galleries638.9145 
663LES_int_01639.0463Mm-hm.639.4107
664LES_se0_ag4_m_01639.7926Ideally,640.5960
666 640.7058you know, our pie in the sky vision,642.4209 
668 642.7457is that the s-643.5492 
670 643.9004the information, which is getting to be quite considerable,646.2755 
672 646.7058um,647.0043 
674 647.0965that we647.7711 
676 648.7677put together,649.6414 
678 650.2867would eventually651.3799 
680 651.5731be a seminal force that could start maybe654.2935 
682 654.8379an African American museum here in656.5677 
684 656.6906Lower Manhattan, and none exist.658.5521 
686 658.6443You know.658.8287 
688 659.0965[You have]659.3935 
689LES_int_01659.0965[Yeah.]659.3935
690LES_se0_ag4_m_01659.5648sure, you have the burial ground,660.8868
692 661.2292but they're all661.7868 
693LES_int_01661.9624Yeah.662.3048
694LES_se0_ag4_m_01662.3927very /sple-/662.8010
696 663.0512but there isn't a663.6483 
698 663.8722a repository of information that tells about666.1229 
700 666.5839the kind and quality667.8219 
702 668.0590of contribution that African Americans made to life in Lower Manhattan.671.4521 
703LES_int_01671.5136Right.671.8297
704LES_se0_ag4_m_01672.5277And672.7780
706 673.2263and so eh- the thing of it is that the first thing I did was I had to try to676.4455 
708 676.5664figure out, well, what's gonna be678.2115 
710 678.6479our679.0123 
712 680.6323focus.681.2908 
714 681.6289Cause one of the first bit of data that we uncovered, was that the very first non-indigenous person to live in this city687.0055 
716 687.4094was a person of African decent. He was a Afro-Portuguese sailor,690.5649 
717LES_int_01690.8634[Hm.]691.1444
718LES_se0_ag4_m_01690.9688[who] sailed into the harbor in 1613 on a Dutch ship,694.3626
719LES_int_01694.7621[Wow.]695.1177
720LES_se0_ag4_m_01694.9202[As-] as a translator, because he knew Indian dialect somehow.697.7544
721 698.1935[And] uh.698.9706
722LES_int_01698.1935[Hm.]698.4306
723LES_se0_ag4_m_01699.4300He was abandoned in the harbor.700.5539
725 701.4013Had a argument with the ship's captain, he left him here, they sailed off [without him.]704.5359 
726LES_int_01704.0837[Oh no. (laughing)]705.0540
727LES_se0_ag4_m_01705.3027And he co-habited with the Rockaway Indians and707.7700
729 708.1125quite frankly, we give him credit for having started the African American population here,711.6692 
731 712.0906in uh,712.5675 
733 713.1867i- in Manhattan.714.1745 
734LES_int_01714.2755[Yeah.]714.6706
735LES_se0_ag4_m_01714.3984[And] that was in 1613.715.6935
736 716.0930And it was about eight716.8745
738 717.0150years later or so when the first718.7140 
740 718.8438nine or ten719.9111 
742 720.4379uh,720.6530 
744 721.3467African721.8999 
746 722.0886female slaves were brought into the harbor.724.5648 
748 725.0813Um.725.4676 
750 726.2008As a work force.727.3599 
752 727.5574[And then,]728.1238 
753LES_int_01727.5574[Mm.]728.0535
754LES_se0_ag4_m_01728.5321the whole slave trade began to730.0292
756 730.1872to burgeon.730.8765 
757LES_int_01731.0830Right.731.6138
758LES_se0_ag4_m_01731.8759Now, people.732.3896
760 733.0877There's slavery in New York, well what kind of /they-/, you know, enlightened bastion, of- of,736.9404 
762 737.1556you know737.4453 
763LES_int_01737.6209The [North, /inaudible/ yeah,] yeah, [no I.]740.7336
764LES_se0_ag4_m_01738.0073[progress in the North. Yeah, you know what I-]739.6712
766 740.1322[Yeah.]740.4834 
767 740.7732And so the whole [thing was]742.0289
768LES_int_01741.3440[It's very true.]742.1782
769LES_se0_ag4_m_01742.2792The whole thing was, was that there was no city744.4172
771 744.6719in this country, during the height of the slave trade747.0279 
773 747.7348that had more slaves748.8675 
775 749.9826than New York.750.5885 
777 751.3574You know, the only city wa- there was one city. It was Charleston, South [Carolina.]754.6809 
778LES_int_01754.3472[<laugh> Right.]755.1989
779LES_se0_ag4_m_01755.5633Right?755.7769
781 756.4618They had a756.7911 
783 757.4365burgeoning slave market, and we had a slave market here at Forty Wall Street.760.9180 
785 761.1989where of a given morning, you could buy a slave, you could rent a European worker, or- or- or- or766.0180 
787 766.2638an Indian767.0848 
789 767.6189cook, or whatever.768.5057 
790LES_int_01768.5716Yeah.768.8833
791LES_se0_ag4_m_01769.1730You know.769.4189
793 769.5462Yo-769.7306 
795 769.8887They dealt in flesh, right there, Forty Wall Street.772.0487 
797 772.6414So,773.0102 
799 773.3175s- th- th- thi- whi- that774.6199 
801 775.5726really775.9150 
803 776.9555caused me to777.8336 
805 778.1101or res-778.6150 
807 778.7116and it778.9838 
809 779.1111allowed me779.9042 
811 780.3433to sort of780.9184 
813 781.0649fine tune781.9562 
815 782.3337what the mission would be about.783.5059 
817 784.2479My experience with the Tenement Museum,785.8400 
819 787.7366used to make me very angry.788.7289 
821 789.3523because, almost everything that they do is791.4782 
823 791.6450proscribed by792.6197 
825 792.8129the building793.4143 
827 793.7568that they have794.2573 
829 794.4065okay, they.794.8675 
830LES_int_01794.8675Right.795.3592
831LES_se0_ag4_m_01795.3592Okay.795.6402
832 795.9563Which was fine,796.7851
834 797.6280but,797.8388 
836 798.7124what it does799.8363 
838 800.1788in the way they800.7407 
840 801.1534present801.9158 
842 802.3856is it creates the impression803.8695 
844 804.2558that804.5851 
846 805.5422immigration806.3149 
848 806.5695meant807.1534 
850 808.9607that great809.4700 
852 809.7114in-migration that took place in the middle nineteenth century.812.7934 
854 813.5646You know, all these Europeans came,815.1012 
855LES_int_01815.2417[Hm.]815.4173
856LES_se0_ag4_m_01815.4085and settled in the Lower East Side,816.8749
857 817.0680and they lived in these tenements,818.4861
859 818.7539and819.1710 
861 819.2588that was it. And I said to myself, well820.8422 
863 821.2153you know821.5666 
865 821.6763there was an African American population here in the823.6827 
867 823.9530seventeenth century,824.9721 
868LES_int_01825.0775[Hm.]825.2575
869LES_se0_ag4_m_01825.2575And in the eighteenth century, it was a Hispanic population,828.0310
870 828.3120and a l- very large830.0637
872 830.3535a830.5335 
874 831.3720Indian population and832.8340 
876 833.2397and833.5866 
878 833.7358and, and Chinese, and834.8670 
880 834.9636you know, and I said,835.6924 
882 836.0173they were the people837.1851 
884 838.2256who built838.8578 
886 838.9763the infrastructure of the city.841.0382 
888 841.5782Bec- otherwise,842.9260 
890 843.0138those European immigrants could not have got from Ellis Island846.7397 
892 846.9460to the Lower East [Side, there was just no way.]849.3080 
893LES_int_01847.8197[<laugh>]849.3080
894LES_se0_ag4_m_01849.7119You found somebody put the streets and the roads and all that [stuff in-]852.8494
895LES_int_01852.4499[Yeah. (laughing)]852.8494
896LES_se0_ag4_m_01853.2709in place.853.7758
898 854.0919And so, that's what gives us our focus now, is that856.7261 
900 857.0597that part of history is the story yet to be told.860.1923 
901LES_int_01860.2450Mm.860.6928
902LES_se0_ag4_m_01860.8026And so, we're working hard862.3611
904 862.7782at- at863.1953 
906 863.3445developing that part of it.864.6513 
908 864.9191[Um.]865.2704 
909LES_int_01864.9191[Yeah.]865.2704
910LES_se0_ag4_m_01866.0123<ts> We meet roadblocks because there are a lot of people who don't like competition in New York City.870.1990
911LES_int_01870.7391Right.871.0728
912LES_se0_ag4_m_01871.0728You know because everybody's competing for the same dollars.873.6455
913 873.7684[You know.]874.1196
914LES_int_01873.7684[Sure.]874.1196
915LES_se0_ag4_m_01874.2777Me-874.4884
916LES_int_01874.8177[Sure.]875.1909
917LES_se0_ag4_m_01875.1294[You] know what I mean.]875.8450
918LES_int_01875.9065[Yeah.]876.3060
919LES_se0_ag4_m_01876.2006[Yeah.] And so we,877.2264
920 877.5469but- but, we're, you know, we're pushing on, we're persevering as best we can.881.5421
921LES_int_01881.9723Yeah.882.2709
922LES_se0_ag4_m_01882.3060Um.882.7319
924 883.5425We're now884.2143 
926 885.0177I got a couple or few grants886.5367 
928 886.9626b- this year887.7704 
930 888.3455um,888.7143 
932 888.8680to, uh,889.3801 
934 889.7094do certain things, like we built a website.891.6411 
936 892.1811Um.892.6772 
938 893.3928Wa- we- we're developing a curriculum895.4591 
940 896.1835um,896.3986 
942 896.6182that896.8377 
944 897.0133we hope will get New York State898.3084 
946 898.8133approval899.4938 
948 899.6299so that900.1392 
950 900.9392if a teacher wants to bring a class from anywhere in the state,903.6437 
952 904.1222um,904.3856 
954 905.8256that we will send them information to use in the classroom about909.1388 
956 909.3758you know909.7358 
958 909.8807African American history910.9827 
960 911.2505[you know, or]911.5842 
961LES_int_01911.2971[Mm-hm.]911.5842
962LES_se0_ag4_m_01911.6939par-911.8827
964 912.0100particularly in New York City913.1439 
965LES_int_01913.3678Mm-hm.913.7103
966LES_se0_ag4_m_01913.7103and914.1669
967 914.4654then they'll be the visit,915.4225
969 915.7649and then916.2786 
971 916.4279we'll give them917.1742 
973 917.3674materials to use post visit.918.9727 
975 919.5303You know.919.7498 
977 920.1669So we're hoping to get that set, because once we do that, then922.7571 
979 923.1567uh, o- one thing we can do is that we can get funding for926.4438 
981 926.7555those,927.2033 
983 927.5458um,927.8224 
985 928.9770inner city schools,930.1404 
987 930.4418so to speak,931.0257 
989 931.4779who s-932.1277 
991 932.5667can't afford to pay.933.4228 
992LES_int_01933.7530[Mm-hm, mm-hm.]934.6969
993LES_se0_ag4_m_01933.9330[for a- a tour.]934.7312
994 935.2252And so, we can give that funded, and you know, uh,937.2828
996 937.4013expose the938.3540 
998 938.4726the- the materials that were developing pretty rapidly,941.0174 
1000 941.4784to a wider942.8130 
1002 942.9403audience.943.5638 
1003LES_int_01943.6033[Mm-hm.]943.9018
1004LES_se0_ag4_m_01943.9018We're now members of the945.0477
1005 945.4676the International Coalition of Historic Sites of Conscience948.8701
1007 949.1642that949.4013 
1009 950.0028you know,950.3277 
1011 950.4199and we've had visitors from all over the world come here.953.3467 
1012LES_int_01953.3993[Mm.]953.8384
1013LES_se0_ag4_m_01953.5925[You know.]953.8647
1014LES_int_01954.0491[Mm-hm.]954.3345
1015LES_se0_ag4_m_01954.3389Um, in the last955.3969
1017 955.5067seven or eight years, and so, the- there is an awareness building958.4993 
1019 958.9998um,959.5486 
1021 960.2730<ts> I- I960.8701 
1023 960.9886put us into the uh,962.0116 
1025 962.8925the um,963.4632 
1027 963.6696the North East African American preservation group966.2774 
1029 966.3872that's run out of the National Trust for Historic Preservation, so we're- we're connecting and-970.2184 
1031 970.5432and networking with a lot of other sites [around,]972.7867 
1032LES_int_01972.3871[Mm.]972.7006
1033LES_se0_ag4_m_01973.2916you know.973.5989
1035 974.3189A- and so, that's what I've been doing975.9506 
1037 976.0471you know, I- I am the busiest retired person in America, I'm [seventy nine years old, I work] too hard,981.3555 
1038LES_int_01979.2142[<laugh>]980.6405
1039LES_se0_ag4_m_01981.8648you know, but, uh,982.8658
1040LES_int_01982.8658<laugh>983.6121
1041LES_se0_ag4_m_01984.4902The opposite of that is boredom.985.8882
1042LES_int_01985.8882Yeah (laughing) [<laugh>]987.6136
1043LES_se0_ag4_m_01986.3317[right?]986.5907
1045 986.6829[So I- uh,] So,988.0746 
1046 988.7814But, um989.3390
1047LES_int_01989.3390But, it's important work.990.2522
1048LES_se0_ag4_m_01990.3663Yeah, and- and so, ye- so, you know the st-992.6039
1050 992.7882the sum of it all is- is that I've- I've been here on the Lower East Side995.6419 
1052 997.0863I f-997.2751 
1054 997.5298maintain a legal residence, put it that way.999.4951 
1055LES_int_01999.6048Yeah.999.9253
1056LES_se0_ag4_m_01999.9385For1000.2019
1058 1000.8956fifty two years or something.1002.2030 
1059LES_int_011002.4717Wow.1002.8756
1060LES_se0_ag4_m_011003.2312And um.1003.7785
1061LES_int_011004.7663Lemme ask you a little bit about, uh,1006.8297
1063 1007.5278your memories of the neighborhood.1008.9810 
1064LES_se0_ag4_m_011009.5254Well, I just- [/what I was just about to ??/]1011.2646
1065LES_int_011010.7421[Yeah, oh yeah, great.]1011.5412
1066LES_se0_ag4_m_011012.0614Um.1012.4127
1068 1014.5639What I remember about this neighborhood was that1016.6214 
1070 1017.6619it was1018.2370 
1072 1018.4829a lot1018.8605 
1074 1019.2468it was always a busy place. It's very busy right now.1021.8513 
1075LES_int_011022.0577Yeah.1022.3035
1076LES_se0_ag4_m_011022.5011Kay.1022.7206
1078 1023.2415And, you know1024.0976 
1080 1024.4006e-1024.5235 
1082 1024.7474as a1025.1425 
1084 1025.3094youngster growing up in Brooklyn,1026.8328 
1086 1027.0128my grandmother, and my mother, and her sister, they were both master seamstresses.1031.1682 
1087LES_int_011031.5677Mm.1031.8750
1088LES_se0_ag4_m_011031.8750And, so they, they worked.1033.2492
1089 1033.4950They-1033.6575
1091 1033.7540they made1034.1616 
1093 1034.2845clothing for very-1035.2284 
1095 1035.4791for1035.6196 
1097 1035.7205wealthy, private customers who lived in Brooklyn Heights and places like [that.]1039.3893 
1098LES_int_011039.0776[Okay.]1039.3893
1099LES_se0_ag4_m_011039.9556And so every Sunday,1041.0049
1101 1041.3404you know, my grandmother, and my mother and my aunt, and they would all schlep us1045.0644 
1103 1045.1917o-1045.2708 
1105 1045.3937me, myself, and my cousin,1046.7547 
1107 1047.1103over here to Orchard Street1048.5201 
1109 1048.6738around1049.0557 
1111 1049.5123to buy [f-]1050.0991 
1112LES_int_011049.8884[Ah. Yeah.]1050.7840
1113LES_se0_ag4_m_011050.6742fabric [and notions]1052.0747
1114LES_int_011051.1967[Fabric.]1051.5567
1115 1052.3689[Yeah.]1052.6762
1116LES_se0_ag4_m_011052.4698[a-] and things of that sort, [you know.]1054.1513
1117LES_int_011053.7913[Right.]1054.0986
1118LES_se0_ag4_m_011054.6255And1055.1918
1120 1055.2884and I remember the-1056.0508 
1122 1056.1737I remember egg creams a- and Charlotte [Russe and]1059.0186 
1123LES_int_011058.4693[<laugh> Yeah.]1059.6854
1124LES_se0_ag4_m_011059.3786[I mean] very vividly, you know, that was an important part of my life.1062.1835
1125 1062.6270And-1062.8773
1127 1062.9695because we used to have to carry the stuff back, so we would always get rewarded.1066.1744 
1128LES_int_011066.3500[<laugh>]1067.1124
1129LES_se0_ag4_m_011066.9324[before] the fact.1067.6656
1130 1068.2582Um.1068.6490
1132 1069.0968But, i- i- i- it was always an interesting neighborhood to me1071.9724 
1134 1072.1129and1072.4246 
1136 1073.3890what1073.6348 
1138 1073.8280interested me about it,1074.9826 
1140 1075.4392the- as a youngster growing up,1077.1163 
1142 1078.4378and now1079.1651 
1144 1079.5953even,1079.9904 
1146 1080.3038was the heterogeneity. I mean1082.0555 
1148 1082.1697this is the most incredible thing, I'm- I'm still1084.5700 
1150 1084.6798you know,1085.0530 
1152 1085.1759overwhelmed by a walk from here to China Town. You know, you1088.0032 
1154 1089.0086there's no telling where a person is from, [right?]1091.0687 
1155LES_int_011090.8360[Yeah.]1091.3716
1156LES_se0_ag4_m_011091.5121That you might encounter.1092.4165
1157LES_int_011092.5745Right.1092.8256
1158LES_se0_ag4_m_011092.8256And that makes it so,1093.7775
1159 1093.9224so very exciting.1094.8399
1161 1095.1545You know.1095.3696 
1163 1095.8438Then,1096.1994 
1165 1096.5023um.1096.8096 
1167 1097.4331A- as a youth,1098.2584 
1169 1098.5482growing up in-1099.3077 
1171 1099.4307in-1099.7116 
1173 1099.9224in Brooklyn1100.5985 
1175 1100.7038and going to high school1101.8306 
1177 1101.9799on the1102.2389 
1179 1102.8536in Lower Manhattan on fifteenth street,1104.3462 
1181 1104.5106[it's /unintelligible/, it was]1105.7336 
1182LES_int_011105.1365[Mm. Mm-hm.] Mm-hm.1106.3348
1183LES_se0_ag4_m_011106.5853So, I would get off the subway every day,1108.6384
1185 1109.9292a- the F train, Second Avenue stop1111.8126 
1186LES_int_011112.1720Yeah.1112.5769
1187LES_se0_ag4_m_011112.5633and Houston1113.4154
1188 1113.5252and I would walk to Fifteenth Street.1115.4306
1190 1115.8915and so the- I knew everything. I mean I knew the sec- the Yiddish theater, I knew who the actors were, I [knew all the] delicatessens.1122.1857 
1191LES_int_011120.9257[Right.]1121.2857
1192 1122.4842Yeah.1122.7784
1193LES_se0_ag4_m_011122.7988<blows nose> Excuse me.1123.7822
1195 1124.8227And so1125.2837 
1197 1125.7930I had-1126.3988 
1199 1127.8965I had an incredibly rich1129.6833 
1201 1129.8326life.1130.3945 
1203 1131.2989Because of all of the infusion of all these1133.5365 
1205 1133.9096various [cultures.]1135.0335 
1206LES_int_011134.8711[Sure.]1135.3365
1207 1135.5121Yeah.1135.7536
1208LES_se0_ag4_m_011135.9204Now,1136.3023
1210 1137.9048the thing about it1138.7374 
1212 1139.2599then, and you have to forgive me, I have a really bad sinus [condition.]1142.4692 
1213LES_int_011142.0872[Oh, don't worry about it.]1142.8775
1214LES_se0_ag4_m_011142.6316[It-]1142.8819
1215 1143.3209Um.1143.5843
1217 1144.1588The thing about it1145.0149 
1219 1146.2662now1146.6745 
1221 1146.9511as opposed to then,1148.1672 
1223 1149.2955is that1149.7740 
1225 1150.8920it seems to be becoming1152.3320 
1227 1152.8150so rapidly, a neighborhood for the privileged.1155.5238 
1228LES_int_011156.0638Yeah.1156.3272
1229LES_se0_ag4_m_011156.8086Mm.1157.0413
1231 1158.6174And.1158.9642 
1233 1160.3560I mean, there were always people of wealth here.1162.0857 
1235 1162.4984There ar- there was always an incredible1164.2267 
1237 1164.5954you know, artistic community1166.1233 
1239 1166.3691it dispersed,1167.1374 
1241 1167.7828at- at least1168.5599 
1243 1168.6916I know for the last1170.0467 
1245 1170.1784seventy-odd years or more.1172.0047 
1246LES_int_011172.0706Yeah.1172.5711
1247LES_se0_ag4_m_011172.7072Um.1172.9442
1249 1174.1340But we1174.5540 
1251 1174.6330went down the entire socioeconomic scale.1177.2979 
1252LES_int_011177.4867Mm-hm.1177.9213
1253LES_se0_ag4_m_011177.9828And then, during the thirties,1179.1506
1255 1179.2604particularly, and right up until nineteen forty-two1181.8182 
1257 1182.0948everybody was poor.1183.5436 
1259 1185.0012Cause1185.2163 
1261 1185.3348the Great Depression was upon [us.]1187.0411 
1262LES_int_011186.7689[Right.]1187.3167
1263LES_se0_ag4_m_011187.6294As a- <cough> nobody had any (coughing) you know, very few people.1190.5621
1264LES_int_011190.0836[Was no wealth (laughing) <laugh>]1191.5625
1265LES_se0_ag4_m_011190.9134[Right, that's right.]1191.8787
1266 1192.2650And- and so, that was an interesting phenomenon, in it of itself, it had the-1195.2647
1268 1195.4666the-1195.6290 
1270 1195.7388the-1195.9891 
1272 1196.3008the effect of1196.9227 
1274 1197.0763bonding together, people of-1198.6305 
1276 1198.7227of very diverse backgrounds, and ethnicities, and things, cause we were all in same boat.1202.8852 
1277LES_int_011203.3297Yeah.1203.6327
1278LES_se0_ag4_m_011203.6398You know.1203.9295
1280 1204.2588And then, along came World War Two, and of course people began to1207.0144 
1282 1207.1637do a little better because of1208.4325 
1284 1208.5247there were opportunities that1209.6486 
1286 1209.9734to earn1210.6173 
1287LES_int_011211.1046[Yeah.]1211.5305
1288LES_se0_ag4_m_011211.2056[um,]1211.4866
1289 1211.8597and1212.1627
1291 1212.3163the like.1212.7071 
1293 1213.1812But now,1214.0681 
1295 1215.4554it seems like1216.1271 
1297 1216.5310all those people who1217.5041 
1299 1218.7159their image counterparts,1220.3666 
1301 1220.4983i- in- in the1221.4773 
1303 1222.0964thirties, forties, fifties, and sixties, and even1224.6939 
1305 1224.9222s-1225.1593 
1307 1225.4578even1225.9407 
1309 1226.8934seventies and eighties,1227.9866 
1311 1229.6139who used to work hard1231.0802 
1313 1231.6510and achieve1232.6739 
1315 1233.3456a- and raise their families and the like, and enjoy1236.4305 
1317 1236.8300the neighborhood and it's vibrancy and it's character1239.4422 
1318LES_int_011239.6266Yeah.1239.8637
1319LES_se0_ag4_m_011240.0305are replaced1241.0344
1321 1241.4075by a much smaller group of very bright, very intelligent, very hard working people who are m-1245.4554 
1323 1245.6091earning1245.9647 
1325 1246.3335incredible amounts of money,1248.1056 
1326LES_int_011248.2285Yeah.1248.5402
1327LES_se0_ag4_m_011248.6149and so they've raised a- the- the-1250.6520
1329 1251.0691the cost of everything1252.1930 
1331 1253.4630to the degree that it's pricing other people out.1255.4606 
1332LES_int_011255.7635Yeah.1255.9654
1333LES_se0_ag4_m_011256.0093Poor people1256.6284
1335 1256.8172are just being forced right out1258.6727 
1337 1259.2566of the neighborhood.1260.0337 
1339 1260.6220and I think that's a1261.4342 
1341 1261.5703very very1262.3386 
1343 1262.4879dangerous thing1263.7128 
1345 1264.0772particularly for New York.1265.4059 
1347 1265.7659It's not as if we were just a small community, a suburban community somewhere,1269.9806 
1349 1270.3669and the character1271.0635 
1351 1271.1996could change and1272.1259 
1353 1272.3937and another one similar to it would s-1274.1454 
1355 1274.3518sn-1274.6108 
1357 1274.7250you know, spring up adjacent,1276.0245 
1359 1276.2264i-1276.3845 
1361 1276.4767adjacent to it.1277.1617 
1362LES_int_011277.2978Yeah.1277.5876
1363LES_se0_ag4_m_011278.0837What this is, is that there are people who are going to be displaced.1281.9674
1365 1282.3933With no real concern for what happens to them.1285.0819 
1366LES_int_011285.7185Mm-hm.1286.1400
1367LES_se0_ag4_m_011286.4692You know.1286.7107
1369 1287.1717And that's part of the reason why1289.3785 
1371 1289.8826those lots are still empty.1291.4814 
1373 1292.7355over there1293.4028 
1375 1293.5126[on-]1293.7497 
1376LES_int_011293.5556[Yeah.]1293.9670
1377LES_se0_ag4_m_011293.9033on-1294.1097
1378 1294.2194on, uh,1294.6321
1380 1294.7331Broome1295.2994 
1382 1295.5014and Delancey and you know,1297.0687 
1383LES_int_011297.2795Yeah.1297.5692
1384LES_se0_ag4_m_011298.1487Essex to I guess Norfolk, or thereabout1300.3614
1385LES_int_011300.4624[Yeah.]1300.7781
1386LES_se0_ag4_m_011300.4927[Y-]1300.6922
1387 1300.8663That's about [it right?]1301.6039
1388LES_int_011301.2391[That's about right.]1301.8449
1389LES_se0_ag4_m_011302.3048And1302.6121
1391 1302.8009And1302.9941 
1393 1303.1928a- i- i- as I see it,1304.6679 
1395 1304.7908and I read it,1305.4318 
1397 1306.2425It's because guys like Sheldon Silver, and- and1308.8810 
1399 1309.0567and, and his cohorts1310.4484 
1401 1310.8698they really don't care1311.7947 
1403 1312.4400about us.1313.1688 
1405 1313.6166And then you have1314.4332 
1407 1314.5298the- the- there is another1315.7547 
1409 1316.1323effort1316.4352 
1411 1316.6942to1316.9577 
1413 1317.7420to create1318.2732 
1415 1319.2040in fact it's i-1320.0090 
1417 1320.1715it's not even so subtle.1321.5484 
1419 1322.0752i- they1322.4572 
1421 1322.6459i-1322.8259 
1423 1322.9225i-1323.1025 
1425 1323.5986this area's being marketed as the-1325.8597 
1427 1325.9871the1326.2856 
1429 1326.5878cradle of American Jewry.1328.2832 
1431 1328.4061Okay.1328.8056 
1433 1329.0383I mean, that's alright, but1330.1403 
1435 1330.5592as long as you1331.2485 
1437 1331.4460realize that1332.0548 
1439 1332.9460there are a lot different kinds of people rocking that cradle.1334.8645 
1440LES_int_011335.3211[<laugh>]1336.4275
1441LES_se0_ag4_m_011335.7777[A-]1335.9972
1443 1336.1772[And]1336.6909 
1444 1336.9851[that]1337.4680
1445LES_int_011337.2579[<laugh>]1337.4855
1446LES_se0_ag4_m_011337.7299and b- b- but, the thing of it is, is that1340.2938
1448 1341.2597they're trying to control1342.8446 
1450 1342.9412the character1343.9187 
1452 1344.0504of the neighborhood.1344.8889 
1453LES_int_011344.8743Mm.1345.3372
1454LES_se0_ag4_m_011345.3411See, one of the founders of this church,1347.3650
1456 1347.9050James P. Allaire,1348.9412 
1458 1349.2924built the very first tenement1350.6273 
1460 1351.1893down here in Lower Manhattan.1352.5415 
1461LES_int_011352.7159Okay.1353.1665
1462LES_se0_ag4_m_011353.2512Okay.1353.5849
1464 1354.0941He rented it to whoever could pay the eight dollars or so.1357.2112 
1465LES_int_011357.5449Yeah.1357.7776
1466LES_se0_ag4_m_011357.7776You know, for a three hundred and seventy five dollar square- a three hundred seventy five1360.9239
1467 1361.2400square foot1362.0566
1469 1362.1795apartment, that was so small, you had to come outside to change your mind, [right?]1365.4356 
1470LES_int_011365.1255[<laugh>]1366.7104
1471LES_se0_ag4_m_011365.9975[And-]1366.2610
1473 1366.3839[And] it was a bathroom in the hallway.1367.9205 
1474 1368.2278Now, that [same] space, that same amount of space if it still exists,1371.7065
1475LES_int_011368.6800[Yeah.]1368.9873
1476LES_se0_ag4_m_011372.0336has been redone, redecorated, bathrooms moved inside, and suddenly you're gonna cost fifteen hundred dollars a month.1377.2616
1478 1377.8719So,1378.2143 
1480 1378.6534you could see how it's leap-frogged over a substantial population of people who would like to stay in the neighborhood and rent that kind of space, they [can't.]1385.7465 
1481LES_int_011385.5493[Yeah.]1385.7908
1482LES_se0_ag4_m_011386.5854They really can't.1387.1123
1484 1387.4108And so, tha- tha- those,1388.5435 
1486 1388.6664those lots over there are being- the Seward Park thing.1391.6260 
1488 1392.2407It- it-1392.6035 
1490 1392.6826they're being fought over vigorously, and have been for years,1395.3431 
1492 1395.6021because as I understand it, and I don't really know1397.8631 
1494 1398.0607all the1398.6973 
1496 1398.8762you know1399.2010 
1498 1399.6593specifics1400.4276 
1500 1401.3348a- as I understand it is that1402.9812 
1502 1403.2753the- there are1403.7758 
1504 1404.1183a certain1404.6583 
1506 1405.4661percentage of the housing1406.8710 
1508 1407.2997to be developed there1408.2304 
1510 1408.6870is supposed to be designated1409.9953 
1512 1410.4168as1411.0227 
1514 1412.2614below1412.8051 
1516 1412.9632market rate income.1413.8046 
1517LES_int_011414.0241Right.1414.3314
1518LES_se0_ag4_m_011414.4983Okay.1414.8363
1520 1415.6266That's a game.1416.4958 
1522 1416.9524I mean, that's the biggest1418.1598 
1524 1418.3310charade1419.0319 
1526 1419.4314since, I don't know, since Cheez-its.1421.6310 
1528 1422.1358A- y- you-1422.8339 
1530 1423.0271you know, y-1423.4793 
1532 1423.6110Look take Harlem, for example.1425.4131 
1533LES_int_011425.4131Mm.1425.7205
1534LES_se0_ag4_m_011427.9902You've got1428.4424
1536 1429.0967a situation where Harlem is being gentrified rapidly. You've got churches buying property and buildings and things like that, and they1434.9702 
1538 1435.2360and they're rationalizing, like, oh yeah, we're gonna put a lot of1437.9031 
1540 1438.0617e- lower income housing, like1439.8898 
1542 1440.3374okay.1440.6965 
1544 1441.4239But the low1442.0600 
1546 1442.1673income housing1443.2024 
1548 1444.8251is pegged1445.7530 
1550 1447.3469to1447.7246 
1552 1448.5033a median income- i- is only a- like a small t-1451.5529 
1554 1451.8734ten, fifteen, twenty percent max,1453.5195 
1556 1454.1303pegged to a median income of like1456.3312 
1558 1456.6016forty thousand dollars1458.2931 
1560 1458.7827forty-five1459.3796 
1562 1459.8645and the median income in Harlem is like fifteen thousand dollars.1463.7903 
1564 1464.1120So,1464.5270 
1565LES_int_011465.0959Yeah.1465.4223
1567 1466.1310Those definitions are very tricky, but1467.8707 
1568LES_se0_ag4_m_011468.7510So, [wha- wha- what does that mean?]1470.0865
1569LES_int_011468.9152[Low, affordable, me- moderate, what do they mean? Yeah.]1472.7246
1570LES_se0_ag4_m_011470.9052[Yeah.]1471.3995
1572 1471.7585[Exactly.]1472.3927 
1573 1472.9429And1473.3253
1575 1473.4372and- and- it's re- very frustrating to me1475.5412 
1577 1476.0448because I recall having gone to a meeting a couple of years ago over at that-1479.3113 
1579 1480.0341that um,1480.6309 
1581 1480.8128building that the Chinese have over there on Houston Street1484.0057 
1583 1485.2274Um.1485.6564 
1585 1487.2966The- I think it's1487.9960 
1587 1488.2478near Christy, or one of those. They- they have a- like a f-1490.2342 
1589 1490.3461a community center facility.1491.8895 
1590LES_int_011491.8895Okay.1492.2475
1592 1492.4004Mm-hm.1492.7269 
1593LES_se0_ag4_m_011492.6496And1493.0308
1594 1493.6836i- i- this whole question, you know, of-1495.8285
1596 1496.2855of um,1497.0083 
1598 1497.8895of restoration and preservation1499.6183 
1600 1499.7209was being argued vigorously there.1501.6793 
1601LES_int_011501.9218[Mm-hm.]1502.3275
1602LES_se0_ag4_m_011502.0057[And they invited] developers.1503.4326
1603 1503.6377And i- the guys were re- oh look, there's no money in low income housing, you know, so it-1507.6767
1604LES_int_011507.2990[Right.]1507.6767
1605LES_se0_ag4_m_011508.0683That- that was their whole thing, we wanna make money, we have to make a living, and so.1511.7649
1606LES_int_011512.4037Right.1512.6042
1607LES_se0_ag4_m_011512.9132The- and, and I think that that's-1514.3808
1609 1514.7993that's what1515.2469 
1611 1515.8717what- what we're facing1517.1540 
1613 1517.4478with that.1517.8861 
1615 1518.2172I1518.4503 
1617 1518.7161quite honestly1519.7792 
1619 1521.1443I'm not so sanguine that1522.4826 
1621 1522.7484w-1522.8976 
1623 1523.2380we can really win that battle.1524.4690 
1625 1525.8492I think you have to fight it.1526.9858 
1626LES_int_011527.3122Right.1527.8951
1627LES_se0_ag4_m_011527.9790You know, you don't have an option.1529.0002
1628LES_int_011529.3825Yeah.1529.6250
1629LES_se0_ag4_m_011530.3617But, I- I'm just a-1531.6021
1630LES_int_011531.6907How do you see the battle in what,1533.5958
1631LES_se0_ag4_m_011535.2371Well, I just1535.7128
1633 1535.9692[uh I see-] I see1537.2702 
1634LES_int_011535.9692[/unintelligible/.]1536.7293
1635LES_se0_ag4_m_011537.4194the1537.6934
1637 1537.8519the developers1538.8032 
1639 1538.9803being rich enough to prevail.1541.2418 
1640LES_int_011541.5391Mm.1541.9681
1642 1542.5929Mm-hm.1542.9147 
1643LES_se0_ag4_m_011543.0266You know1543.3250
1645 1543.4323The.1543.5768 
1646LES_int_011543.5768Yeah.1543.9685
1648 1544.1830Yeah.1544.4721 
1649LES_se0_ag4_m_011544.9617[The- That's what] it really boils down to.1547.0040
1650LES_int_011545.0864[Um.]1545.5195
1652 1546.7173[/Huh/.]1547.2039 
1653 1548.0050If it were up to you,1549.0409
1655 1549.2041what'd you l- what would you like to see1550.5097 
1656LES_se0_ag4_m_011550.6731If [it were up to me,] I'd like to see r-1552.9113
1657LES_int_011550.8408[developed there?]1551.5682
1658LES_se0_ag4_m_011553.0698quite frankly,1553.7459
1660 1553.8858a mixture,1554.7660 
1662 1555.3069given all of these modern1556.9448 
1664 1557.6209co-op1557.9707 
1666 1558.3250type buildings [going,]1559.5333 
1667LES_int_011559.1690[Yeah.]1559.6908
1668LES_se0_ag4_m_011559.7286And, [given a hotel]1561.2720
1669LES_int_011560.1436[/inaudible/]1560.8850
1670LES_se0_ag4_m_011561.5424on every block from Essex1563.4230
1672 1563.7534back up to Allen,1564.7694 
1674 1564.9139you know,1565.1517 
1676 1565.5426it's just ridiculous.1566.5731 
1677LES_int_011566.4472It's insane.1567.2690
1678LES_se0_ag4_m_011567.5756I would like to see1568.6693
1680 1569.0983middle1569.6486 
1682 1569.9610to lower1570.6418 
1684 1570.8796income [housing] develop.1572.2750 
1685LES_int_011571.4544[Okay.1571.7714
1686 1572.3403Yeah.1572.5828
1687LES_se0_ag4_m_011572.7739I- I think enough already1574.1670
1689 1574.5633with this1574.9457 
1691 1575.0716upper income1575.8550 
1693 1576.2840enough already with the threats about gentrifying certain of the public housing. Cause we know the city wants out of the public housing business.1582.6896 
1695 1583.2398I said, it's getting to be quite a miasma here1586.2436 
1697 1586.5747of-1586.9104 
1699 1587.0270of1587.1715 
1701 1587.6938this community1588.6497 
1703 1589.1006being1589.6648 
1705 1590.0145sort of1590.4976 
1707 1590.6095taken over, slowly but surely1592.7492 
1709 1593.0943by those persons who find it1594.7305 
1711 1594.9181in their best interest to work close to the financial district.1597.8360 
1712LES_int_011598.6846Yeah.1598.9877
1713LES_se0_ag4_m_011599.4820You know.1599.7291
1714LES_int_011599.8923Yeah.1600.1840
1715LES_se0_ag4_m_011600.7130And1601.0907
1717 1601.2865I say1601.9615 
1719 1603.2671that1603.6681 
1721 1603.9805be-1604.1950 
1723 1604.8105because-1605.7058 
1725 1607.6817For1608.1153 
1727 1608.9500a couple a hundred years now1610.5954 
1729 1612.4466this has been a real neighborhood.1613.9376 
1730LES_int_011614.3386Yeah.1614.5531
1731LES_se0_ag4_m_011615.2898You know.1615.6768
1733 1616.2177And- and the people who have made it thus1618.9502 
1735 1620.0774should have some entitlement1621.4017 
1737 1621.5229for their progeny, for their children.1623.9383 
1739 1624.4279Their children ought to be able to-1626.2546 
1741 1626.6323to1626.9121 
1743 1628.7633to feel the vibrancy of the neighborhood when they walk through the streets [here.]1632.6310 
1744LES_int_011632.3605[Yeah.]1632.6310
1745LES_se0_ag4_m_011632.8035They- they [should be able to] feel like1633.8946
1746LES_int_011633.1579[So.]1633.5309
1747LES_se0_ag4_m_011634.0765I belong here.1634.8272
1748LES_int_011635.0137So, for you, if there were housing built on that /??/ in the neighborhood,1638.9174
1750 1639.3604do you feel that-1640.2416 
1752 1640.3862that1640.6986 
1754 1641.2617the people who should move in1642.8564 
1756 1643.2294to the new housing sounds like should be1645.3837 
1758 1645.6355local-1646.2277 
1760 1646.8012local residents, or the children of-1648.6730 
1762 1648.9434of other folks, I mean who sho- I guess I'm asking, who should that housing be for?1652.1770 
1763LES_se0_ag4_m_011652.5594Uh. I, you know1653.5433
1765 1653.8557the1654.1121 
1767 1655.6917I think that the local residents1657.4356 
1769 1657.6268ought to have some1658.7039 
1771 1659.5841priority on a list1660.7451 
1772LES_int_011661.0212[Hm.]1661.3482
1773LES_se0_ag4_m_011661.0575[that they] develop1661.6451
1774LES_int_011661.8237Yeah.1662.1699
1775LES_se0_ag4_m_011662.2746but, I don't think it should1663.2305
1777 1663.3097the- tha-1663.5942 
1779 1663.7107that should mean that1664.6853 
1781 1665.3381people of the same1666.3098 
1783 1666.9067income strata1667.8253 
1785 1668.3662should be precluded from having1669.9737 
1787 1670.1649to- moving into [the neighborhood.]1671.5677 
1788LES_int_011670.9196[Right.]1671.2094
1789 1671.6244[Right.]1671.9275
1790LES_se0_ag4_m_011673.0932Do you know what I mean1674.2309
1791LES_int_011673.5976[Yeah.]1673.9676
1792LES_se0_ag4_m_011674.3335let's keep e- turning it over, that's fine, that's how it always has been.1677.4619
1793LES_int_011677.6170Right.1677.9574
1794LES_se0_ag4_m_011678.0646You know.1678.3957
1796 1678.6895But I think that1679.6369 
1798 1679.7861i- if there are locals who are really in need of housing an- and who are1683.8055 
1800 1684.0900deserving of the improved housing situation,1686.9052 
1801LES_int_011686.9052Yeah.1687.1990
1802LES_se0_ag4_m_011687.2922give them some priority.1688.2994
1803LES_int_011688.4626Right.1688.6957
1804LES_se0_ag4_m_011689.0828Tha- that's- that's not a problem.1690.5842
1805LES_int_011690.8034Yeah.1691.0179
1806LES_se0_ag4_m_011691.1251You know.1691.3676
1807LES_int_011691.6054What do you think about building height?1693.2502
1809 1694.0056That's something [people are] opinionated [about.]1696.2252 
1810LES_se0_ag4_m_011694.6211[Well,]1694.9289
1812 1696.1273[That's] something that's bothering me these [days.]1697.9878 
1813LES_int_011697.7928[Yeah.]1698.1611
1814LES_se0_ag4_m_011698.4456Uh, but I1699.1263
1816 1699.3315you know1699.7185 
1818 1699.8444I- I can deal, I live in a building that's twenty one stories, and I hardly know it because it's not1704.2687 
1820 1704.7629So imposing, and it's right on the river, you know,1706.6739 
1821LES_int_011706.6739Is it the East River, [/inaudible/]1708.3805
1822LES_se0_ag4_m_011706.9397[The s-]1707.1216
1824 1707.7604[Yeah, I live in the East River.]1708.7918 
1825 1709.2618Um.1709.5509
1827 1709.9240And I- but, I think that's high enough.1711.6761 
1828LES_int_011711.8020Yeah.1712.1750
1830 1713.3733So, you wouldn't want to see anything higher than that?1714.9263 
1831LES_se0_ag4_m_011714.8562No.1715.2199
1832 1715.5463No, no, no, na- I think it would, it would1717.3963
1834 1717.6807change the character.1718.8837 
1836 1719.2661It would make us look like Hong Kong1720.9354 
1838 1721.4530or [Tokyo.]1722.1851 
1839LES_int_011721.6488[<laugh>]1722.6933
1840LES_se0_ag4_m_011722.6933Or- or even Beijing.1724.3522
1841 1724.7578You know, all these1725.4293
1843 1725.5086a- al-1725.9189 
1845 1726.0868different, well,1726.6883 
1847 1727.3504Malaysia, I mean I [uh,]1728.8940 
1848LES_int_011728.6196[<laugh>]1729.7201
1849LES_se0_ag4_m_011729.1021[I had an office in] Tokyo for thirteen years,1730.8664
1850 1731.0763so I bummed around a lot in Southeast [Asia.]1733.0028
1851LES_int_011732.8302[Yeah.]1733.3105
1852LES_se0_ag4_m_011733.4970And1733.8794
1854 1734.2792A- And I'm always amazed at the kind of1736.7413 
1856 1737.0816o- of construction1738.4898 
1858 1738.8162that they've built.1739.3125 
1859LES_int_011739.5950[Yeah.]1739.8701
1860LES_se0_ag4_m_011739.6976[But,] that was a f- we-1740.6873
1861 1741.1864but the see uh- New York City has the same excuse.1743.7139
1863 1744.5765Many of those1745.5604 
1865 1745.8728were built1746.2972 
1867 1746.4177because there isn't that much1747.8958 
1869 1748.0497space to build on.1749.1594 
1871 1749.8635So, everything went vertical1751.1680 
1873 1751.6156You know.1751.9154 
1874LES_int_011751.9094[Yeah.]1752.3710
1875LES_se0_ag4_m_011752.2371[And] there are all these incredible1753.4855
1876 1753.7139arguments going on1754.8890
1878 1755.2014i- in this city right now for1756.6422 
1880 1756.7903air rights.1757.5737 
1882 1757.9980[Uh, you're gonna] fight somebody1759.6393 
1883LES_int_011758.0178[I know.]1758.5571
1884LES_se0_ag4_m_011759.9371to-1760.0730
1886 1760.1569about1760.4693 
1887LES_int_011760.3015[For air.]1760.8657
1888LES_se0_ag4_m_011760.7025seven million dollars worth of air1762.3392
1889LES_int_011762.6178Oh. [It's so crazy.]1764.1239
1890LES_se0_ag4_m_011763.1960[Is i- it doesn't even make sense.]1764.7021
1891LES_int_011764.3739It's mix- it's insane.1765.5181
1892LES_se0_ag4_m_011765.5134Yeah.1765.8771
1893 1766.1289But, [but] that's [what's happ-]1767.6117
1894LES_int_011766.3947[For you]1766.7444
1896 1767.2807[Buy the air] rights of it.1768.5472 
1897LES_se0_ag4_m_011768.6843That's what's happening1769.4805
1898LES_int_011769.4805[I'd um.]1770.0773
1899LES_se0_ag4_m_011769.7696[Right?]1770.0773
1900LES_int_011770.2732Yeah.1770.6649
1901LES_se0_ag4_m_011770.6649Right, so.1771.2430
1902LES_int_011771.7886It's not1772.2969
1903LES_se0_ag4_m_011772.2969No, I y- I- I -1773.2854
1904 1773.5932[uh. I.]1774.0921
1905LES_int_011773.5932[So, do you] di- do you think1775.0200
1906 1775.1657the- though that given the fact that that land, in particular has been vacant for forty years, people fight over it, I mean do you think that there's a possibility for it to-1783.5275
1908 1783.9938for people to reach a compromise somehow? You know, the fights have been over1787.2511 
1910 1787.7641the type of housing, you know, just what you're saying, [you know.]1790.1785 
1911LES_se0_ag4_m_011789.7449[Yeah.]1790.1226
1912LES_int_011790.4769What does affordable mean? Some people want all, some people wanna build luxury1794.1370
1914 1794.2258condos, and they can't-1795.3960 
1916 1796.0348they can't seem to agree.1797.1823 
1917LES_se0_ag4_m_011798.0356I- I, what I think1799.2573
1919 1800.0453I- I think1800.9080 
1921 1801.4255it's only gonna be resolved1803.0877 
1923 1803.9410in the same way that Harlem-1805.2792 
1925 1805.4937the Harlem situation [has been resolved.]1807.2423 
1926LES_int_011806.4219[Hm.]1806.8602
1927LES_se0_ag4_m_011807.3729In that1807.9623
1929 1808.3960the poor are really gonna lose.1809.9161 
1931 1811.1918You know.1811.4669 
1933 1811.9419They'll be just enough1813.1776 
1935 1813.4574y- you see, people who are in1814.5438 
1937 1814.6464in- in- who have power, prestige, or money1816.7798 
1939 1817.1389are very reluctant to give it up.1818.6101 
1940LES_int_011818.8597Mm.1819.2254
1941LES_se0_ag4_m_011819.2303They'll control the distribution of it.1821.0768
1943 1821.4545So, a few1822.5083 
1945 1823.4315will have access, [but]1824.6439 
1946LES_int_011824.3583[Yeah.]1824.6439
1947LES_se0_ag4_m_011824.7978only a few.1826.0742
1948LES_int_011826.3400Yeah.1826.5825
1949LES_se0_ag4_m_011826.7317You see.1827.1374
1951 1827.5151Because they're g- the rationalization's gonna be1829.7859 
1953 1830.5693and- and1831.0449 
1955 1831.2676it'll be true in a lot of instances,1832.7410 
1957 1832.9602the- for some people,1833.9254 
1959 1834.3404is that1834.8067 
1961 1835.6460a person isn't gonna wanna pay a million and a half dollars for a condominium or a co-op1840.9350 
1963 1841.5085and live in the same building1843.2804 
1965 1843.5882with somebody1844.4030 
1967 1844.6362who1845.1211 
1969 1845.8485earns less than1846.7298 
1971 1847.1448thirty thousand dollars a year.1848.4644 
1973 1849.1685Well, that's a real snobbish kind of an attitude to have.1851.9091 
1975 1852.5946You know, as if money defines you1854.3338 
1977 1854.6183Well, in this country, it does.1855.9880 
1979 1856.3051In the world, it really does.1858.0490 
1981 1858.1656Uh. You know.1858.7065 
1983 1859.1215E-1859.3033 
1985 1859.4339E- unless you're1860.4504 
1987 1860.5390in a country1861.2711 
1989 1861.3690where1861.7595 
1991 1861.9600there is a-1862.3890 
1993 1863.3169a more humane attitude toward you're fellow1865.4712 
1995 1865.5598men.1865.9328 
1996LES_int_011866.0774[Mm-hm.]1866.6062
1997LES_se0_ag4_m_011866.1100[And] that generally1867.4576
1998 1867.7968Doesn't1868.1279
2000 1868.5709exist1869.2470 
2002 1869.3356these days1869.9837 
2004 1870.2495in1870.4220 
2006 1870.5899to1870.7811 
2008 1870.9816to great a degree1871.8769 
2010 1872.2592in America.1873.0519 
2011LES_int_011873.2291Right.1873.5917
2012LES_se0_ag4_m_011874.2072Cause you know.1874.8320
2013LES_int_011875.1631Lemme ask you about the Lower East Side as a neighborhood. So, first of all, what, uh, where are the boundaries for you of the Lower East Side?1881.5351
2014LES_se0_ag4_m_011882.3418The [boundaries?]1883.2853
2015LES_int_011882.9356[Well, like] geographic boundaries.1884.4696
2016LES_se0_ag4_m_011885.2903Well, actually,1886.3103
2018 1887.5880i-1887.7605 
2020 1888.0310i- the Lower East Side1889.3552 
2022 1889.4718these days, goes from1891.1644 
2024 1891.7007I think Fourteenth Street down to1893.5413 
2026 1893.6346the Brooklyn [Bridge.]1894.4879 
2027LES_int_011894.3480[Brooklyn] Bridge. Yeah.1895.2480
2028LES_se0_ag4_m_011895.3692Um, and from the East River, probably over to Broadway.1898.5069
2029LES_int_011899.1364Uh-huh.1899.4302
2030LES_se0_ag4_m_011899.7053Okay.1900.1658
2031LES_int_011900.1658Yeah.1900.5015
2032LES_se0_ag4_m_011900.5015Which is pretty [wide.]1901.7605
2033LES_int_011901.5364[That's] a big. Yeah. [Yeah.]1902.8330
2034LES_se0_ag4_m_011902.4692[Yeah.]1902.8190
2035LES_int_011903.0987And there are some people that1904.3531
2037 1904.5489that view1905.3509 
2039 1905.4908north of Houston Street1906.7160 
2041 1907.1123As a [separate s-]1908.2921 
2042LES_se0_ag4_m_011907.5524[A- a- as a- I do.1908.8592
2043LES_int_011908.4413[East Village.]1909.4817
2044LES_se0_ag4_m_011909.0166[I personally]1909.7965
2045 1910.0004I- I- I see that as East-1911.5265
2047 1911.6524East [Village.]1912.4730 
2048LES_int_011912.2725[Yeah.]1912.5243
2049 1912.7155Yeah.1912.9813
2050LES_se0_ag4_m_011913.0186And- and that's1914.0386
2052 1914.1598it's not Lower East either.1915.5680 
2053LES_int_011916.1229[Right. <laugh> Right.]1917.5265
2054LES_se0_ag4_m_011916.2069[<laugh> You know (laughing) it's neither.1917.6011
2055 1917.8435South of Houston.1918.8834
2056LES_int_011919.1352[Mm-hm.]1919.5781
2057LES_se0_ag4_m_011919.3636E-1919.5583
2058 1919.7075And so, n- you've got all these appellations, you know, Noho and Soho [and]1923.8529
2059LES_int_011923.7410[<laugh>]1924.9860
2060LES_se0_ag4_m_011924.4078[And everything] else, and everybody's1926.0153
2061 1926.1086desperate to try to find a way to- to-1928.2675
2063 1928.4214to1928.6871 
2065 1928.9529spike the value of real estate.1930.9860 
2066LES_int_011931.3438Oh, right.1931.8195
2067LES_se0_ag4_m_011931.9220You know.1932.2718
2068LES_int_011932.5469Right.1932.8546
2069LES_se0_ag4_m_011933.0225So.1933.2976
2070LES_int_011933.4002So, uh, so if we have1934.9343
2072 1935.0835these boundaries for the Lower East side, um,1937.4056 
2074 1937.6248who makes up1938.1354 
2076 1938.3313the Lower East Side community, is it everybody who lives within those streets?1942.6038 
2077LES_se0_ag4_m_011945.7442I think it probably should be everybody who lives and works1948.2295
2079 1948.5419within [those boundaries. Yeah.]1950.0232 
2080LES_int_011948.8574[Lives and works. Yeah.]1950.0465
2081 1950.1630Well, I guess I, I guess I should ask1951.7781
2083 1952.2724how you define community, right? Like what does it mean to be a part of a community?1956.6555 
2084LES_se0_ag4_m_011957.8294Well, in New York, that's a very funny thing.1959.8392
2085LES_int_011960.0630Yeah.1960.3288
2086LES_se0_ag4_m_011960.4733You know.1960.8137
2088 1961.2567Um.1961.6717 
2090 1962.5903I- I think that-1963.4564 
2092 1963.6662that1963.9040 
2094 1964.1838the- the only definition that is universally applicable1967.2520 
2096 1967.7136is that you live there.1969.1731 
2097LES_int_011969.5217Mm-hm. [Mm-hm.]1970.2071
2098LES_se0_ag4_m_011969.8714[Okay.]1970.2071
2099 1970.6454But, a lot of people live1971.5221
2101 1971.7086in what we call1972.4873 
2103 1972.6365New York style.1973.7696 
2104LES_int_011974.5763[<laugh> What's that?]1975.9180
2105LES_se0_ag4_m_011975.0659[You know, and] and it's very important.1976.7667
2106LES_int_011977.0418[Yeah.]1977.3524
2107LES_se0_ag4_m_011977.1490[Um] in in other words, that means that1979.4292
2108 1980.2126I can s- you can- you and I can live on the same floor in an apartment building, and I'll acknowledge your presence in the morning, and1985.6017
2110 1985.7230you know, say good morning, it's like1986.6089 
2112 1986.8700but I don't want anything to do with you1988.4741 
2114 1988.7352I don't wanna go in your apartment1990.0735 
2116 1990.2460[unnecessarily,] or you- have you in mine.1992.6334 
2117LES_int_011990.2460[Yeah.]1990.5538
2118 1992.6334Yeah.1992.9738
2119LES_se0_ag4_m_011993.1976You know?1993.5147
2121 1993.7933And- and- so tha- that's something that we've discovered here that's changed the character of ministry.1998.5495 
2122LES_int_011998.8805Mm.1999.4448
2123LES_se0_ag4_m_011999.5147Okay.1999.9192
2125 2000.1430Whereas before,2001.0150 
2127 2001.4393people who were doing ministry2002.8429 
2129 2003.1786you had access o-2004.2044 
2131 2004.4185you would just visit every Sunday after church, you would knock on doors, and2007.6473 
2133 2007.7918cadge your dinner or something, you know?2009.1347 
2134LES_int_012009.2327Yeah.2009.5264
2135LES_se0_ag4_m_012009.5310<laugh>2009.9344
2136LES_int_012010.1279Yeah.2010.3797
2137LES_se0_ag4_m_012010.3797But, but now,2011.4196
2138 2011.9791um.2012.3407
2140 2012.8350A person's home is really a sanctuary.2015.1618 
2141LES_int_012015.4369Mm.2015.9964
2142LES_se0_ag4_m_012016.2995You know, it's where they go2017.7590
2144 2017.8849to get away from the vicissitudes of-2019.6410 
2146 2019.9161of2020.1912 
2148 2020.4244the city and the neighborhood2021.8046 
2150 2021.9305[in a] lot of instances.2023.1522 
2151LES_int_012021.9305[Right.]2022.3082
2152 2023.1522Yeah.2023.5287
2153LES_se0_ag4_m_012023.7152You know.2023.9297
2155 2024.1116So, that's why I say,2025.0022 
2157 2025.2586l- people have adopted this whole thing of living for years2028.7045 
2159 2028.9377adjacent to somebody and not really knowing them well.2031.4358 
2160LES_int_012031.6223Yeah.2031.8881
2161LES_se0_ag4_m_012032.6109You know.2032.8813
2163 2033.1191Which is okay, I- I- I don't see anything wrong with that.2035.9527 
2164LES_int_012036.0646No.2036.2884
2165LES_se0_ag4_m_012036.6848But so- so that- but that does2038.4742
2167 2039.3088in my judgement2040.1622 
2169 2040.6564create a definition of2041.8548 
2171 2042.0693who live- of the ne- who's in the neighborhood.2044.2830 
2172LES_int_012044.7167[Right.]2045.0384
2173LES_se0_ag4_m_012044.8146[Just] by virtue of [presence.]2046.2647
2174LES_int_012046.1715[Right,] right.2046.8709
2175 2047.2947Ho-2047.4346
2177 2047.5745Um, how does the African American community in the Lower East Side fit into the larger2052.5917 
2179 2053.0855community?2053.7710 
2180LES_se0_ag4_m_012054.4611Well.2054.8668
2182 2056.6468You know, it's always been2058.0504 
2184 2059.6731a difficult thing.2060.5497 
2185LES_int_012061.4077Really?2061.7294
2186LES_se0_ag4_m_012063.7146So, you're starting with the fact that2065.4166
2188 2067.5476the African American community was heterogeneous from s- let's just say2070.9783 
2190 2071.6777early nineteenth century.2072.6942 
2192 2073.0999Some were enslaved,2074.1631 
2194 2074.3682some were free,2075.1504 
2196 2075.6307some were very poor. Most.2077.2254 
2197LES_int_012077.5285Mm.2077.7756
2198LES_se0_ag4_m_012077.8456But, they were, for example,2079.2445
2200 2079.5429the- they were2080.0558 
2202 2080.4895African Americans who owned2082.0923 
2204 2082.5260farmland. Viable farmland2084.5357 
2206 2084.8435from Chatham Square up to Aster Place, along the Bowery.2087.6121 
2207LES_int_012087.6867Mm-hm.2087.9571
2208LES_se0_ag4_m_012087.9571They were- they owned businesses in the West Village, a- you know, in Greenwich Village and places like [that.]2092.8162
2209LES_int_012092.6543[Uh-huh.]2093.1613
2210LES_se0_ag4_m_012093.2406And, a-2093.7861
2212 2094.1592and so a- what- I guess what I'm saying is that they- they-2096.2714 
2214 2096.4626always run2097.4838 
2216 2097.6517the-2097.8615 
2218 2098.0849the whole2098.5559 
2220 2098.7331gamut of2099.2040 
2222 2099.5398this economic scale2100.6588 
2223LES_int_012100.7288[Okay.]2101.0226
2224LES_se0_ag4_m_012100.9386[from] enslaved to free, from poor2103.0043
2225 2103.2689to wealthy.2103.9077
2226LES_int_012104.0523Right.2104.2994
2227LES_se0_ag4_m_012104.2994Okay.2104.6912
2228 2105.6377The problem has been, and then, this is the problem for persons of color2109.4591
2230 2109.7901almost everywhere.2110.6321 
2232 2111.9132Is that2112.2909 
2234 2112.7432and- and in a- in a2113.6245 
2236 2113.9276a neighborhood that's in a constant state of flux2115.9460 
2238 2116.7759like thes-2117.3068 
2240 2117.4349Lower East Side.2118.0756 
2241LES_int_012118.0756Yeah.2118.3188
2242LES_se0_ag4_m_012118.9238Is that the newer2120.0222
2244 2120.1443residents2121.5315 
2246 2122.1723almost immediately2123.8884 
2248 2125.0191adopt,2125.6654 
2250 2126.8070as a defense mechanism,2128.2593 
2252 2128.9453all of the prejudices and biases that they find when they get here.2132.4480 
2253LES_int_012133.4796Hm.2133.8885
2254LES_se0_ag4_m_012134.1020Okay.2134.5231
2256 2135.0357So,2135.5482 
2258 2136.1157you have this peculiar thing2137.6291 
2260 2138.2271where you have2138.8712 
2262 2139.0360for example,2139.7560 
2264 2140.3113a dark skinned2141.4463 
2266 2142.0931Dominican2142.8254 
2267LES_int_012143.0817Mm-hm.2143.4478
2268LES_se0_ag4_m_012143.9055Who definitely has2145.0753
2270 2145.4536African blood. You can tell by the shape of their hips. It's steatopygic all the way.2149.6637 
2271LES_int_012149.8895Mm-hm.2150.2186
2272LES_se0_ag4_m_012150.2186You know.2150.5241
2273 2152.5378Getting very offended if you tell 'em- if you2154.5716
2275 2154.9743even s-2155.4930 
2277 2155.7493think that they're black. They could be black n-2157.8179 
2279 2157.9705as ink.2158.6356 
2280LES_int_012158.6905Hm.2159.1360
2281LES_se0_ag4_m_012159.1360But i-2159.5263
2282 2159.7948i- [i-]2160.2524
2283LES_int_012160.0327[Right.]2160.4477
2284LES_se0_ag4_m_012160.4477But,2160.6430
2285 2160.8687Right away, no no, I'm- I'm from Dominican Republic.2163.3523
2287 2163.9117As i- as if that made a big difference.2165.6325 
2289 2165.8949[You know.]2166.1512 
2290LES_int_012165.8949[<laugh>]2167.0665
2291LES_se0_ag4_m_012166.7431[Um.]2167.2224
2292LES_int_012167.7044Right.2168.1194
2293LES_se0_ag4_m_012168.4198But- but-2168.9019
2295 2169.0056but that's what happens.2170.3281 
2297 2170.6461And so,2171.1587 
2299 2171.5492Wha- what- what2172.1147 
2301 2172.5357part of that,2173.2863 
2303 2173.8878is that their children2175.3584 
2305 2176.5301adopt a really negative attitude toward their peers who are African Americans and it sort of perpetuates2182.5093 
2307 2183.0707the whole thing.2183.8213 
2309 2184.3447For years on the Lower East Side, Allen Street2187.4018 
2311 2187.9387e-2188.0974 
2313 2188.2805and- was- it-2189.3096 
2315 2189.8710was the dividing line between2191.5729 
2317 2191.6583Chinese community, Hispanic community.2193.4890 
2318LES_int_012193.7331Mm.2193.9649
2319LES_se0_ag4_m_012193.9649And2194.2644
2320 2195.2110both communities were fearful of crossing the l-2197.4077
2322 2197.5664street2197.8959 
2323LES_int_012198.0179[Mm-hm.]2198.7502
2324LES_se0_ag4_m_012198.2864[to go] into the other side.2199.4703
2325LES_int_012199.5801Right.2199.8608
2326LES_se0_ag4_m_012199.9401Because of these attitudes2201.3416
2328 2201.7443that they found when they got here that they adopted for defense mechanism that they helped to perpetuate by virtue of2207.6234 
2330 2208.7607behavior of the same manner.2210.1337 
2331LES_int_012210.1337Mm-hm.2210.4693
2332LES_se0_ag4_m_012210.5609So,2210.9026
2334 2211.9277there, it's2212.6051 
2336 2213.7645<ts>2213.8499 
2338 2215.1642African American community,2216.4090 
2340 2216.5310on the Lower East Side2217.6660 
2342 2218.7949is still2219.4113 
2344 2219.6492fighting2220.2351 
2346 2220.3694for its manhood2221.4555 
2347LES_int_012221.6630Mm-hm.2222.0475
2348LES_se0_ag4_m_012222.0475just as African Americans have been2224.1039
2349 2224.7671in this country for four hundred [years.]2226.4391
2350LES_int_012226.0180[Mm-hm.]2226.4391
2351LES_se0_ag4_m_012227.0958[/??/]2227.4509
2352LES_int_012227.0958[Do you] these affect2228.8654
2353 2229.4024tensions2230.1102
2355 2230.2506within the2230.8242 
2357 2231.7935the different groups within the neighborhood?2233.5278 
2358LES_se0_ag4_m_012233.5278Do I see tension?2234.3882
2359LES_int_012234.5469Yeah.2234.9069
2360LES_se0_ag4_m_012235.5415I2235.8771
2362 2236.3226I th- I think2237.2775 
2364 2239.3827I- I think2239.9441 
2366 2240.6031somewhat l-2241.2561 
2368 2241.8236less2242.5131 
2370 2242.8853than say twenty,2243.7306 
2372 2244.1883twenty-five years ago.2245.2134 
2373LES_int_012245.2134Mm-hm.2245.5124
2374LES_se0_ag4_m_012245.5124Because younger people tend to be freer thinkers [nowadays.]2248.5279
2375LES_int_012248.0702[Mm.]2248.5279
2376LES_se0_ag4_m_012248.9459A- and so2249.4855
2378 2249.8193there's-2250.1244 
2380 2250.2735you know,2250.4428 
2382 2250.6274there's a diminution of that.2252.0248 
2383LES_int_012252.0248Yeah.2252.3665
2384LES_se0_ag4_m_012252.7082Um,2253.0005
2386 2253.4344but you still have their parents and their grandparents, you know,2256.5561 
2388 2256.9039who hang on to these old shibboleths, you know, they don't know2259.5783 
2390 2259.8407what to make of anything2260.9573 
2391LES_int_012261.0794Yeah.2261.4455
2392LES_se0_ag4_m_012261.4543And so, they sort of perpetuate it.2262.9931
2394 2263.4935[Um.]2263.9085 
2395LES_int_012263.7254[Yeah.]2264.0183
2396LES_se0_ag4_m_012264.4515Y- you can have, for example, young Asians2266.8940
2398 2267.2357who have2267.8520 
2400 2268.2304African American friends whose grandparents2271.1106 
2402 2271.2326don't want in the house.2272.4668 
2403LES_int_012274.4989Right.2274.8772
2404LES_se0_ag4_m_012275.6033e- the- it's-2276.5858
2405LES_int_012277.0089Yeah,2277.4632
2407 2277.6064still exists.2278.5279 
2408LES_se0_ag4_m_012278.7536So, it's- So I guess maybe we're a couple of decades away.2281.4508
2410 2281.8230[You know (laughing)]2282.5203 
2411LES_int_012282.1769[Yeah. <laugh>]2283.2525
2412LES_se0_ag4_m_012283.3257You know, from a real sort of freedom in that [respect, you know.]2286.6636
2413LES_int_012285.8947[Yeah, well I hope so.]2286.9199
2414LES_se0_ag4_m_012287.2006Yeah.2287.4752
2415LES_int_012287.4536/?/2287.7670
2416 2288.1342Um.2288.6712
2418 2289.3440/RD-NAME-2/ always likes me to ask if there are places in the neighborhood that are important to you, she works on a2295.1838 
2419LES_se0_ag4_m_012295.3608[Well, look.]2296.1298
2420LES_int_012295.3608[this /inaudible/ project.]2296.8025
2421LES_se0_ag4_m_012296.5021[Ma-] /RD-NAME-2/2297.3944
2422 2297.7239/RD-NAME-2/ uh.2298.6026
2424 2300.6712y- you know, the- they installed me in their people's hall of fame thing a couple of years [ago.]2304.4336 
2425LES_int_012304.1529[Okay,] cool.2304.9794
2426LES_se0_ag4_m_012305.4004Uh.2305.6323
2428 2307.0459Every week, when I get to /RD-WORK-4/, I- I told /RD-NAME-2/ this not too long ago, I said2310.7624 
2430 2311.2444ow- I'm s- and I know /RD-NAME-4/ well.2313.4717 
2432 2313.7768you know, the lady that started the whole [thing.]2315.5375 
2433LES_int_012315.2562[Okay.] Yeah.2315.8481
2434LES_se0_ag4_m_012316.1166So,2316.5011
2436 2317.8008I said, I'm so happy that you do this.2319.3752 
2438 2319.7962Because, what it has done for me,2321.4881 
2440 2322.0084in many instances2323.4164 
2442 2323.6727was reminded me of-2324.9663 
2444 2325.0884of several stories that were really important to me in my life.2327.5857 
2446 2328.0678You know.2328.4278 
2448 2328.6597But, the thi- the thing about Red Hook that2330.2463 
2450 2330.3622tha-2330.5575 
2452 2330.8687em-2331.0701 
2454 2331.2165uh- by the Todd Shipyard, I said I learned to swim off the docks down there in Todd Shipyard.2335.2272 
2456 2335.6239And then the thing about the2336.6551 
2458 2336.9846the-2337.1555 
2460 2337.3691the Empire Roller Ring, I said, you know, I threw a picket line around that place, I was sixteen years old because they wouldn't let African Americans2343.5033 
2462 2344.0342skate there then.2344.8718 
2464 2345.2684You know, so uh, I- I think.2346.6353 
2466 2347.1235Yeah.2347.3798 
2468 2347.6483But i- the places on the Lower East Side2350.0708 
2470 2350.3088that were important to me are gone.2352.0458 
2471LES_int_012353.0363Okay.2353.4906
2472LES_se0_ag4_m_012353.6156y- you know, [like,] like [the- the-] um.2355.7392
2473LES_int_012354.2014[Yeah.]2354.4882
2475 2354.8261[Yeah.]2355.1229 
2476LES_se0_ag4_m_012356.5996I can't even remember the name, um- me- the Kosher restaurants that used to be on Essex and Delancey2360.4394
2477LES_int_012360.4760Yeah.2360.8788
2478LES_se0_ag4_m_012361.0130A- and2361.6904
2480 2362.1114a- and2362.7460 
2482 2362.8864and the um2363.8749 
2484 2364.6953the- the- Daily Forward Building is now an expensive co-op, [you know.]2367.7697 
2485LES_int_012367.4768[Yeah. (laughing)]2368.0809
2486LES_se0_ag4_m_012368.4165Y- you know what I mean, t- that's is what mattered to me.2370.8391
2487LES_int_012371.0556[Right.]2371.3674
2488LES_se0_ag4_m_012371.1930[The] stuff that's2371.9557
2489 2372.1526matteri-2372.6957
2491 2372.9581matters to2373.5805 
2493 2374.2090I notice a lot of people who2375.5149 
2495 2375.6003maybe a decade of two younger than me here at the [church]2377.9451 
2496LES_int_012377.5607[Yeah.]2377.9451
2497LES_se0_ag4_m_012378.3357that still exists, like2379.3608
2499 2379.6293e- um.2380.1907 
2501 2380.4043What they call, Edges.2381.4600 
2503 2381.6308You know.2382.1373 
2505 2382.4302The2382.5706 
2507 2382.9977the uh,2383.3577 
2509 2385.1351the- that2385.6659 
2511 2385.9039group there on2386.8253 
2513 2386.9657East Broadway2387.7163 
2515 2387.8322across from the library.2388.8024 
2516LES_int_012389.0099Um. I know [/unintelligible/.]2390.8463
2517LES_se0_ag4_m_012390.0916[Is]2390.4150
2519 2390.6225[you know.]2390.8727 
2520 2391.3608Uh, but2391.9039
2522 2392.2334the- t- w- what's left is2394.0885 
2524 2394.2594Grand Street Settlement, Hendricks Street Settlement,2395.9802 
2525LES_int_012396.6890[The settlement houses?]2397.3968
2526LES_se0_ag4_m_012396.8055[the settlement] houses because they go way back.2399.8219
2527LES_int_012399.9848Yeah.2400.3082
2528LES_se0_ag4_m_012400.3082Um.2400.5217
2529 2400.8024And they still do really good work.2402.7750
2530LES_int_012403.0130Yeah.2403.2510
2531LES_se0_ag4_m_012403.4829Do you know what I mean?2404.1175
2533 2404.2029And- and so they- they've become very important2406.5523 
2535 2406.9794the- the uh2407.8581 
2537 2408.0550n-2408.2624 
2539 2408.6286the incredible synagogue2410.3616 
2541 2410.8192network2411.6064 
2543 2412.8513that's here2413.5591 
2545 2414.0977on the Lower East Side that's2415.5195 
2547 2415.7087running into a lot of difficulty of late.2417.5820 
2549 2417.7102You know, [trying to keep] the buildings going.2419.7987 
2550LES_int_012418.1129[Yeah.]2418.4363
2551 2419.7987Right.2420.1587
2552LES_se0_ag4_m_012420.7140That to me is really important2422.3438
2554 2422.6362you know.2422.9596 
2556 2423.4417Um.2423.7224 
2558 2424.4424Because2425.2601 
2560 2426.2319they were so rich with history and- and stories and things of that sort.2430.7156 
2561LES_int_012430.7353Yeah.2431.0818
2562LES_se0_ag4_m_012431.2967Um.2431.6751
2564 2432.9764They matter.2433.8002 
2566 2434.2578[You know.]2434.7338 
2567LES_int_012434.2578[Yeah.]2434.6303
2568LES_se0_ag4_m_012435.4356Um.2435.7102
2570 2438.4394Aside from that,2439.3242 
2572 2440.5080it's really the parks. The little pocket parks,2443.4737 
2574 2443.9024uh, and the large and small parks2446.1175 
2575LES_int_012446.1175[Yeah.]2446.4531
2576LES_se0_ag4_m_012446.2701[you know.]2446.5569
2577 2447.0694Tha-2447.1915
2579 2447.5759the- the few trees2449.4676 
2580LES_int_012451.1045[<laugh>]2451.9833
2581LES_se0_ag4_m_012451.8246[The] few trees that [you have on the Lower East Side are] really important to [me.]2455.5225
2582LES_int_012452.9962[<laugh>]2454.3458
2584 2455.3455[Yeah.]2455.7544 
2585 2455.9557[Yeah. That's true.]2456.8299
2586LES_se0_ag4_m_012456.1154[You kn- you know.]2456.8299
2587 2457.8734Um.2458.1663
2589 2458.3616Seward Park High School2459.5698 
2591 2459.7895i- is important2460.7841 
2593 2460.9367[you know.]2461.2906 
2594LES_int_012460.9367[Mm-hm.]2461.2906
2595LES_se0_ag4_m_012461.6400I think as an institution, that means a lot to a lot of people I know.2464.5890
2596LES_int_012464.8681[Yeah.]2465.2464
2597LES_se0_ag4_m_012464.8697[You know.]2465.1427
2598 2465.7773So,2466.0824
2600 2466.2288the- the- the2466.9184 
2602 2467.1808[I guess] I've2467.7544 
2603LES_int_012467.1808[Yeah.]2467.4066
2604 2468.4577Uh.2468.8361
2606 2469.1961We- Where do you see the neighborhood going?2470.9025 
2608 2471.7590What do you think's gonna happen to the [whole-]2473.5713 
2609LES_se0_ag4_m_012473.0404[A-] I think- I think the neighborhood is gonna really suffer, the character of it is gonna change because of gentrification,2478.5828
2610 2478.9733and if the economy falters,2480.8788
2612 2481.2693any more,2481.8429 
2614 2482.2334it's gonna be a real disaster.2483.3867 
2616 2483.9542Because the people who have got all these high r-2485.7971 
2618 2486.4089high price, high rent things2487.7636 
2620 2488.0077are not gonna be really able to afford them,2489.5515 
2622 2490.0214and I don't know what that means because the owners of them are not gonna turn them over2494.3189 
2624 2495.6003you know, to people2496.6011 
2626 2496.7414of lesser wealth, I [mean, uh, so.]2498.6896 
2627LES_int_012498.0184[Yeah.]2498.4089
2628LES_se0_ag4_m_012499.0435I- I think this neighborhood is dangerously2501.3684
2630 2501.7712um,2502.0458 
2632 2502.3753on the- one the edge of becoming2503.8109 
2634 2504.1099uh- a miles from s- something that we can't recognize easily.2507.3440 
2635LES_int_012507.2675Mm-hm.2507.9787
2636LES_se0_ag4_m_012508.0702You know.2508.5156
2638 2509.0831[It's re-]2509.4676 
2639LES_int_012509.0831[Do you] think that it's important for us and for the-2512.0199
2640 2512.2640those people who are new to- to really understand the history of the neighborhood?2516.3662
2641LES_se0_ag4_m_012518.6850To really [understand]2519.7956
2642LES_int_012519.0572[Kind of] in order to move forward, I guess, do we need to know about the past?2522.4882
2643LES_se0_ag4_m_012524.0626I think2524.4592
2645 2524.8315a-2525.0084 
2647 2528.3052I don't agree with that.2529.3364 
2648LES_int_012529.3364Hm.2529.6659
2649LES_se0_ag4_m_012530.6057Because2531.3684
2651 2532.8391It- i- the assumption is is that the past is going to be instructive2536.2884 
2653 2536.9230to the-2537.2891 
2655 2537.4112to the2537.7041 
2657 2537.8688present in some way.2538.8574 
2659 2539.0587[In some way.]2539.5896 
2660LES_int_012539.0587[Could it] be, yeah, yeah. [I guess that's what I'm wondering. Is it.]2541.2640
2661LES_se0_ag4_m_012540.3242Um.2540.5988
2663 2540.8551[But, but]2541.3128 
2664 2542.2159to me, at least in New York,2544.6035
2666 2544.8653the present and the future are always dramatically different than the [past.]2548.9861 
2667LES_int_012548.5041[Hm.] Yeah. [Mm-hm.]2550.1482
2668LES_se0_ag4_m_012549.5929And so you, c- I can't even imagine, you know. I mean, Coney Island2552.8687
2669 2553.0151is gone.2553.9610
2671 2554.3725You know, the beach houses at Rockaway2556.1726 
2673 2556.3801are2556.5563 
2675 2556.7210gone.2557.2092 
2676LES_int_012557.6046[Mm.]2557.8637
2677LES_se0_ag4_m_012557.6595[Ta-] Do you know what I mean, and what's gonna be this2560.1032
2678 2560.3168eh- eh-2560.6951
2680 2560.8599it's not gonna be anything like what was.2563.6852 
2682 2564.2542A- and so, that's what I- I see [that as]2566.6585 
2683LES_int_012566.4327[Yeah, yeah.] So it's maybe not relevant.2568.8553
2684LES_se0_ag4_m_012567.1040[A sort of.]2567.6715
2685 2568.8614Not at all. I t- well, it's relevant from a historical point of [view.]2572.2130
2686LES_int_012572.0605[Yeah, yeah.]2572.9087
2687LES_se0_ag4_m_012572.5548[Of what.]2572.9087
2688 2573.1650You know, what a certain group of people2574.8370
2690 2575.0566had to enjoy their lives2577.0597 
2691LES_int_012577.0597Yeah.2577.3954
2692LES_se0_ag4_m_012577.4869and and so you make a comparison between they- the way they enjoy life and the way you enjoy life2581.7844
2694 2582.1566and so you can have some sort of a, you know, thing about that2584.3351 
2695LES_int_012584.5609[Yeah.]2584.8294
2696LES_se0_ag4_m_012584.6646[but,] as far as the- the-2585.9583
2697 2587.4899the development of a new neighborhood,2589.3587
2699 2589.5784the past2590.2680 
2701 2591.2382in my judgement isn't really2592.7576 
2703 2593.1482that informative.2594.3946 
2704LES_int_012594.3946Right, right.2595.3221
2706 2595.9690Interesting, interesting.2597.0002 
2708 2597.2504Listen, I uh, I know I told you we'd keep this as short as possible. I could go on forever.2600.9194 
2709LES_se0_ag4_m_012600.9987I- well I can't2601.9873
2710LES_int_012602.2741This has been great, I mean I- I asked you all my key questions, so2605.6180
2711LES_se0_ag4_m_012605.6180Okay.2606.0360
2712LES_int_012606.0360we can go ahead and stop.2606.8597
2713LES_se0_ag4_m_012607.0001Alright, please.2607.7690